Friday, February 8, 2008

New York Vet, Convicted of Perpetrating Animal Cruelty on the Granddaughter of Seattle Slew (But He Can Still Practice . . . )

The story of this New York vet is worth some attention not only because it shows that State Veterinary Board's allow vets convicted of animal cruelty to continue practising, but also because it provides good insight into what I believe to be a dangerous veterinary personality type. A profiler would certainly find this guy interesting -- his statement in his own defense to the veterinary board is a rambling and disjointed, off topic and self-glorifying rant, which doesn't address in one iota the issues that were being investigated. It paints a picture of someone who lives in his own world, without accountability, divorced from the reality of his actions.

On June 1, 2006, veterinarian Dr. Ronald J. Peters was convicted of Animal Cruelty in Washington County Court in the State of New York. The case involved two horses -- one a mare who is the Granddaughter of Seattle Slew, and her foal. The veterinary board document provides just a few details of the case that gave rise to this charge and conviction, as follows:

"The facts surrounding said crime at that at the Hudson Falls auction in April 2005, respondent purchased a pregnant mare horse, which was in poor condition at the time of purchase."

(This statement in the vet board document contradicts the claims of the horse's former owner. It seems the vet boards routinely take the vets word for everything when a non-veterinarian has a different story -- even this guy.)

The Board document continues:

"He then unjusifiably failed to provide the horse with necessary sustenance resulting in a deterioration of the mare and thereafter the foal's condition." In the statement of charges, the board specifically says that Peters "failed to provide a mare and foal with necessary sustenance, food or drink."

(Like most Board documents, this one doesn't say what happened to the horses. But with a little googling, I learned that the two horses were doing OK -- no thanks to the vet of course. They were bought by an Argyle horse rescue group, Double L Stable Equine Rescue. They were named Delta Dawn (the mom) and Willie (the foal). You can see pics of them here: http://search.petfinder.com/petnote/displaypet.cgi?petid=5196506).

In 2005 the courts sentenced Peters to 3 year's probation in the horse cruelty case. If this probation began at the time of sentencing (which was July 11, 2006) it would continue until July 11, 2009.

In their own investigation of this cse, the veterinary board recommended a penalty of 24 months suspension -- but also recommended that all but 9 months of that suspension should be "stayed." In other words, after 9 months he can practice again. They also fined him $1,000.

This means the guy can practice again around July 2008 -- while still on probation for animal cruelty.

In fact this was not Peters first conviction: According to the North Country Gazette:

"In 1999, Peters was convicted of several misdemeanors for falsely billing the town of Greenwich for disposing of stray dogs. Instead of proper disposal, Peters dumped them on the side of a road."

Subsequent to that, the state office of professional discipline put him on probation for 2 years.

A repeat offender, multiple times on probation, Yet the Board still hasn't seen fit to yank his license. Instead, they fine him $1,000 and stay all but 9 months of his suspension.

Some insight into this guys mind is provided in his statements to the Board. Peters was allowed to write the Board and make recommendations about the penalty to be imposed if he should be found guilty. The written response he submitted upon being given this opportunity is truly astounding. He wrote:

"We live in a world torn by war, ripped by scandal and oppressed by high taxes and sky rocketing energy cost."

Um, what does that have to do with your conviction on animal cruelty????

[He goes on in this vein for a bit . . . blah blah blah]

"I work very diligently to practice medicine & surgery, to the best of my ability to not let me continue to practice would make me a poorer not a better veterinarian in the long run."

Commentary: Yes, of course, it's all about YOU.

He then launches into a dissertation on education -- perhaps because the Veterinary Board operates for some odd reason under the State Education Department in New York -- saying:

". . . in the future I would direct my efforts more toward those with the talent and commitment to help promote education. (By education I mean those looking for honest accurate answers based on Humans, animals & facts to our problems.) I think we have a great state & a great nation but knowledge, honesty, commitment & kindness are not always in control. I'm not saying you can always be kind but you should always try to be. We live in an imperfect world. I feel we should use our knowledge, commitment & concern to make it better deceit & maliciousness make it worse."

I will just let that speak for itself.

But back to the real concern: those who can't speak for themselves. Because sadly, another horse belonging to Peters has since met a very bad fate. The Times Union reported the following on September 15, 2007:

"A car carrying an Argyle couple collided with the horse at 10 p.m. Thursday. Washington County sheriff's deputies said the horse escaped from the farm where veterinarian Ron Peters lives. Peters has not been charged in the car accident, but District Attorney Kevin Kortright said the vet could be held liable in civil court.

The horse was killed and the passenger of the car, Sherry Smith of Miller Road, was unconscious at the scene and flown to Albany Medical Center Hospital. . . . "

The article also provided this synopsis of Peters past:

"Peters was found guilty in 1999 of forgery and larceny and in 2005 of cruelty to animals. In the first case, Peters dumped the body of at least one dog on the side of the road instead of cremating it as he had been paid $25 to do after he removed the head and sent it to a state lab for rabies testing. Two years ago, a jury found Peters guilty of allowing a granddaughter of Seattle Slew to suffer in his care."

The question yet again is: WHAT in the world does a vet have to do in order to have his license taken away by a veterinary board?

Links:

http://search.petfinder.com/petnote/displaypet.cgi?petid=5196506

http://pet-abuse.com/cases/6804/NY/US/

http://www.northcountrygazette.org/articles/060306VetConvicted.html

http://www.oms.nysed.gov/press/DisciplineOct2007.htm

Thursday, February 7, 2008

Ghastly Dastgir in Maryland

Today's bad vet comes from my home state of Maryland.

Ghulam Dastgir has the rare distinction of having had two veterinary board actions taken on his license within a 1-year period. These were in the case of Rae-Rae the Dalmation and T-Jay the Yorkshire Terrier.

Dr. Dastgir owns Suitland Animal Clinic in Suitland, Maryland and Airpark Animal Hospital in Gaithersburg, Maryland. Each of these business is cited in one of the board decisions. He also apparently worked at a third clinic, called "Bonifant."

The Treatment and Death of T'Jay, the 4-month old Teacup Yorkie. T'Jay, the 4-month old TeacupYorkie puppy was originally brough to Dr. Dastgir for his booster shot. No veterinarian was at the hospital when she arrived. So, Dr. Dastgir's daughter - who is not a veterinarian or, apparently a licensed vet tech -- gave the shot to T'Jay.

Shortly thereafter, T'Jay "became lethargic and unresponsive." The owner called Dr. Dhastgir, who told her to bring T'Jay over to the other hospital where he was working. When he got there, he gave T'Jay 1 mg of torbutrol -- an opiate. He sent T'Jay home. Later that night, T'Jay vomited and had diarrhea, and the owner brought him back in.

Then, Dr. Dastgir gave T'Jay 1/2 cc of Gentocin. He did this without recording the concentration of the drug, and the Board says that the "omission is problematic because Gentocin, which comes in two different concentrations, is a weight-dependent medication . . . the dosage or amount that an animal should receive is dependent on weight.

"Dr. Dastgir never weighed T'Jay. [His owner] however estimated that T'Jay weighed less than two pounds"

"The amout of Gentocin that Dr. Dastgir administered to T'Jay exceeded the recommended dosage for a dog T'Jay's size . . . T'Jay died during the night."

The Board found Dastgir in violation of requirements that he supervise non-veterinary staff for allowing his daughter to administer medications without supervision; they also found him to have committed a "record-keeping" violation by failing to write down the dosage or amount of Gentocin given to T'Jay.

Commentary: I think you will agree if you read the above that it seems clear that things more serious than record-keeping violations went on. It is hard to read the above and come to any other conclusion other than that the dog had received an overdose -- in fact, the Board says that no matter which concentration he used, the amount given was excessive. Why didn't the board find Dastgir in violation of provisions against negligence or standard of care? Perhaps becase "record-keeping sounds so much less serious. I can hear them now: "The problem is not that you gave a drug overdose . . the problem is that you failed to document the overdose." Oh, gee whiz, and now the little 4 month old puppy is dead.

RaeRae's Bad Stay. "RaeRae's" owner brought 13-year old Rae Rae to Airpark Animal Hospital for boarding because she was experiencing health problems and was unable to care for RaeRae for a time.

More than a week after dropping RaeRae off, her owner went to visit RaeRae. According to the board documents, she noticed that Rae Rae was nervous and dirty. Rae Rae's owner removed RaeRae but then returned and boarded her again, "after discussing the dog's care with Dr. Dastgir."

For the first several weeks, RaeRae's owner continued to visit and would clean RaeRae's cage when she came. However, her health condition prevented her from visiting Rae Rae the following month. The next time she arrived to visit, she "observed that RaeRae was very skinny, filthy, and wet from lying in her own urine. [She] also observed that RaeRae had no food or water in her cage. She further observed that RaeRae could not stand up, and had an open bedsore on her leg."

The Dr. agreed to treat RaeRae's sore, but three days later the owner returned, and saw that the sore was larger and deeper. She also saw a second wound. "Dr. Dastgir advised [the owner] that RaeRae was paralyed, and would never walk again, and that it was time to euthanize her. "

That day the owner took RaeRae to another veterinary hospital, where she was treated. The new vet who assessed RaeRae noted "that RaeRae: (a) could not walk on entry, but with help was able to stand up and hobble; (b) had a large decubitus ulcer on her right hip and another debucitus ulcer on her right tarsus;" [bed sores]; "was emaciated, but really wanted to eat; and (d) really reeked of urine." The vet treated RaeRae. The Board found "RaeRae [had not been receiving] proper care . . . from Dr. Dastgir and his staff."

Wednesday, February 6, 2008

Texas Dogs "Burchered" by Bad Vet

Summer of 2003 was unfortunately very eventful for the patients of San Antonio vet Jack Burchers. And for two dogs, Diamond and Gizmo, it was their last summer.

Diamond. When Diamond, the Golden Retriever puppy, was brought to Dr. Burchers for her puppy vaccinations, she was coughing. Dr. Burchers gave the vaccinations and informed Diamond's family that the "cough was not a concern" at that time.

A month later, Diamond's family brought Diamond back as she was still coughing. Dr. Burchers then prescribed a dose of antibiotics that was twice the dose that should have been given to a dog her size - - a drug overdose.

Over the next several days Diamond got much sicker, until she was "in a weakened state and had difficulty breathing." The family took her to a different vet. This vet did a fecal test which showed intestinal parasites, and took x-rays, which indicated possible pneumonia. They gave her a transfusion, different antibiotics, and supportive care.

In spite of this care the next day, Diamond died.

Gizmo. Gizmo the dog was in labor when her owner brought her in to Dr. Burchers. Dr. Burchers did a C-section, delivering seven puppies, three of whom died. He also performed an ovariohysterectomy, however, he did not do any pre-op bloodwork.

After the procedure Dr. Burchers used "catgut" stitches and did not prescribe antibiotics.

Approximately 1 week later, Gizmo's family brought her back to Dr. Burchers because they saw that she was bleeding from her incision. Dr. Burcher's said that she had a "hernia" and that part of the omentum (peritoneum) was protruding from the incision site. He performed surgery to fix the hernia but Gizmo stopped breathing during or after the procedure.

The vet board found, in their investigation of this case, that:

Dr. Burchers did not give any supportive fluid therapy to Gizmo prior to either of the surgeries

  • Dr. Burchers did not do any pre-anesthetic bloodwork, nor did he suggest pre-anesthetic bloodwork
  • No written consent forms were used
  • Dr. Burchers did not prescribe any antibiotics for Gizmo after her C-section and hysterectomy
  • Dr. Burchers did not use all available means to revive the puppies that died
  • During the C-section, the amount of anesthesia Dr. Burchers had used was "excessive and could have led to fetal suppression." (Meaning, I presume, could have contributed to the death of the puppies.)
  • Dr. Burchers did not use all available means to revive Gizmo when she stopped breathing after the hernia surgery.
  • Dr. Burchers' use of catgut to suture Gizmo could have contributed to her developing a hernia.
  • Dr. Burchers records contain "no entries on the anesthesia procedures, anesthetic agents, medications, and other details of surgery.
In spite of the fact that the Veterinary Board found that Dr. Burchers had "violated the professional standard of humane treatment" in the case of Diamond and Gizmo, as well as violating recordkeeping rules -- with just a fine, a reprimand, and some homework (continuing education) he was free to keep doing what he does best:

Go right back to "burchering" his patients.

Tuesday, February 5, 2008

"Negligence" in Nevada

Nevada vet Lisa Hayden, DVM, had the dubious distinction of having a complaint filed on her by a member of the Veterinary Board in 2005. The following were among the "stipulated facts and conclusions of law" in the Vet Board's findings:

"Dr. Hayden failed to perform a spay on a dog within the standard of practice of veterinary medicine by ligating both ureters resulting in kidney failure. That conduct is a violation of NRS 638.140 (6), negligence . . . There is no physical examination information prior to the administration of anesthesia or vaccinations."

OK, so I had to look up some of these terms in case you were wondering: the ureter is the tube that takes the urine from the kidney to the bladder. To ligate means to tie. So, if both your ureters are tied off . . .

The findings say that this caused the dog to have kidney failure. Like many Board findings, it does not say whether the dog died, but what do you think? If you search the net for "ligate both ureters" the first things you will see are terminal surgeries on rats. If you make it to page 2 of the Google results, you will find the book, "Practical Gynecology: A Text-Book for Students and Physicians" which tells us: "The most serious injury of the ureter consists in the application of a ligature upon it or upon the tissue about it so that it is laterally compressed. Ligation of both ureters is, without question, fatal . . . "

Then I performed another Google search which yielded some interesting information:

One Lisa Hayden, DVM, is on the Board of Directors for a Nevada Non-Profit called "The Silver Springs Spay-Neuter Project." The stated mission of this non-profit is:

"Building the shelter of tomorrow with aggressive spay-neuter today."

Assuming this is the same Lisa Hayden, DVM, I would say she gives a whole different meaning to the term "aggressive spay."

Hayden was placed on probation for a year, fined $500, and ordered to work 16 hours a month with a "collaborative" veterinarian.

Monday, February 4, 2008

Virginia: Euthanasia by Brain Injection

Today's vet is from Virginia.

Virginia vet Gregory T. Wood, who was "Veterinarian-in-Charge" at Salem Veterinary Hospital in Virginia Beach, Va, was the subject of a Veterinary Board order issued on January 24th, 2006.

The "Findings of Fact" in this order said:

"Staff members report that he is verbally abusive, and, by his own admission, he loses his temper at work."

It further states:

"His technique of injection into the brain is an unnacceptable euthanasia method."

?????!!!!

This was not Wood's first recorded disciplinary action by the State Board. It was the third, the prior two being:

-- a Continuing Education violation in 1999
-- a violation for failure to maintain proper records in 1997

Commentary:

I am just left to wonder if his anger management issues have any direct relationship to his chosen method of euthanasia, which apparently involves shoving needles into pets brains.

These Findings of Fact contain little detail regarding the source of the complaint and other circumstances surrounding the complaint that led to discipline. In both the case in 2006 and in 1997, my guess is that the original allegations were very disturbing. How would it come to the Board's attention that this vet was giving shots into the brain to euthanize patients? What is the story of those patients and what did they endure. As for the 1997 recordkeeping violation case, my review of "record keeping violations" in OTHER cases has demonstrated that when recordkeeping violations are found, more disturbing allegations regarding patient care were in the original complaint.

We will never have more insight into the details of these cases, because complaints are not public in Virginia, as in most states, and there is very little detail in the Board's findings of fact.

Sunday, February 3, 2008

California: Horror on Wheels

Today's Vet is from California.

Vet Boards almost never revoke a veterinary license outright. But sometimes, I guess, even they are shocked into action. And it seems like mobile veterinarian Eugene Kravis did just that.

The California Vet Board's findings tell in painful, horrifying detail the story of four "patients" and Dr. Kravis' treatment of them. They include:

The case of "Daisy Mae," a three year-old springer spaniel on whom Kravis performed surgery -- spay - in his mobile clinic while practising in the Santa Rosa area. "Several hours after Daisy Mae was released, she began moaning," the document says. "Over the next five or six hours Daisy Mae became progressively worse, went into convulsions, and died." A necropsy performed on Daisy Mae showed that "The case of Daisy Mae's death was intra-abdominal hemorrhage caused by loose ligatures on the uterine stump and missing ligatures on the right pedicle. A tied ligature was loose on the uterine stump and no ligature was found on the right pedicle." The Board stated that Kravis' procedure fell below the standard of practice and that specific "failures . . . constituted incompetence in the practice of veterinary medicine and led to Daisy Mae's hemorrhaging and death."

In two other cases, the Board found that Kravis "demonstrated negligence in the practice of veterinary medicine" and "demonstrated incompetence" in the practice of veterinary medicine, respectively.

But perhaps the most horrific case was the fourth described. It is the case of Holly, a border collie/labrador. Holly's owner brought her to Dr. Karvis reporting that Holly had a seizure the day before. Apparently intending to treat Holly for heatstroke and seizures, Kravis "injected 500 ml of Lactated Ringers Solution and 36 mg. of Sleepaway into Holly's abdomen . . . Sleepaway is a euthanasia drug . . .The manufacturer states, 'WARNING. For euthanasia Only. Must Not Be Used for Therapeutic Purposes.' The manufacturer labels Sleepaway with a skull and crossbones and 'POISON.' Sleepaway is highly caustic; it destroys living tissue." The following day, the owner took Holly to another vet. She died that night.

An autopsy was performed on Holly. "The tissues in Holly's abdominal cavity were blackened, chemically burned, fetid and necrotic." The vet board document cites the pathology report which stated, "The generalized necrosis and degeneration is considered to be due to the server irritating action of the components of the improperly used euthanasian soluition [Sleep-Away]. The cause of death is the severe generalized tissue damage that resulted from the injection of the euthanasian solution into the peritoneal cavity."

The board stated: "Sleepaway has no therapeutic use . . . respondent's dilution of Sleepaway likely caused Holly prolonged suffering before her death. His use of Sleepaway on Holly was far below the standard of care and demonstrated incompetence and negligence in the practice of veterinary medicine."

Kravis license was revoked, and he was order to pay Vet Board costs of investigationand prosecution -- an amount in excess of $12,000.

But Kravis had a mobile clinic, and this document states that before coming to California, Kravis was previously licensed in Connecticut and New York. It's hard to imagine another state would issue him a licensed after this, but if a mobile clinic comes to a neighborhood near you, make sure it's not him.

Saturday, February 2, 2008

Pennsylvania: The Vet Who Prayed Nightly that His Client Would "Rot in Hell"

Today's vet is from Pennsylvania.

James Nelson is a practising veterinarian in Pennsylvania. Nelson's elderly client, 76 year-old Betty Voorhies, had brought her 17-year old dog "Lady" to Dr. Nelson for 14 years. Lady was in ill health.

Let's pause for a minute to imagine the bond betweeen a 76 year-old woman and a 17 year-old dog that she has had for that long.

17 is quite old for a dog, and Lady had "lost sight in one eye and had developed breathing problems," according to court documents. Also according to court documents, Dr. Nelson thought that Ms. Voorhies should euthanize Lady, and had told her so.

Ms. Voorhies had made "several appointments for the procedure. However, she changed her mind each time she arrived at Dr. Nelson's office."

(How unusual is that -- for a grieving and attached pet owner to have difficulty going through with a scheduled euthanasia appointment? Not too unusual, it happens all the time.)

These court documents say that "Accordingly, when Ms. Voorhies brought Lady to his office on the day in question Dr. Nelson wanted to get the job done as quickly as possible."

(Does this statement imply that he was rushing?)

With Ms. Voorhies in the room watching, Dr. Nelson did not sedate Lady but went straight to the lethal injection. Court documents say that although Lady was being held by a technician, she was struggling as Dr. Nelson tried to inject lethal solution into her front leg.

Pause to reflect: 76 year-old Ms. Voorhies is watching this.

The first attempt to get the injection into Lady fails, due to the edema and her struggling.

He tries again for the leg. And again, he is unsuccessful.

Pause to reflect: 76 year-old Ms. Voorhies is watching this. And remember - Lady has not been sedated.

Court documents say:

"Finally, Dr. Nelson injected the solution into the dog's jugular vein, causing the dog to howl and collapse."

Pause to reflect: 76 year-old Ms. Voorhies is watching.

Court documents say that after witnessing this, Ms. Voorhies began to cry, and yelled at Dr. Nelson, "accusing him of killing her dog; she demanded that he bring Lady back to life."

Subsequently, Ms. Voorhies filed a complaint with the State of Pennsylvania's Veterinary Board over the "manner in which Lady had been euthanized."

The vet board investigator, Edward Tonelli, called Dr. Nelson in for an investigative interview. During the interview with the Board investigator, Nelson became “angry, loud, and agitated” — and right then and there — called Voorhees, the owner, and tried to persuade her to withdraw her complaint against him. (Or perhaps a stronger word than “persuade” would be more accurate.)

Nelson told Voorhees she would “rot in hell” for what she was trying to do to him. After Voorhees hung up, Nelson called her back two more times, right in front of the investigator. He also called her a “*******wacko” to the Board investigator.

Court documents state that "Dr. Nelson acknowledged to the Board that he continues to pray every night that Ms. Voorhees will rot in hell.”

????

He prays every night that this elderly woman and long-time client -- who watched her beloved dog of 17 go though what certainly sounds like a traumatic euthanasia with no sedation -- will rot in hell because she filed a complaint against him?

I'm willing to bet that Lady was one of Ms. Voorhies primary companions in her golden years -- if not her most beloved companion. Is it any wonder she found keeping that final appointment so difficult? Is it too much to expect that Nelson would have sedated Lady rather than jabbing the needle with lethal meds into her neck with her presumably aware, agitated, and struggling?

In the absence of that, is it too much to expect that this vet feel compassion for this woman who not only just went through one of the most major losses anyone can go through, but who witnessed it occur in a most traumatic way?

Yet, this guy prays every night for her to rot in hell?

Maybe this is one vet you don't want to book a euthanasia appointment with.

I got news for him on that Hell thing, though . . .