David Lacy, DVM of Vernon, Texas, may have a dainty last name, but there was nothing dainty about his handling of the little dachshund "Zeke" when Zeke's owner brought him in to see Lacy in August of 2006.
Zeke's human had brought him to see Lacy because of vomiting and diarrhea. You'd think a vet would handle a dog -- especially a small dog like a dachshund, especially one who is sick -- with compassion. But instead, as Vet Board Findings of Fact show, this isn't how Lacy treated Zeke.
"While preparing for the examination," the Board findings state, the owner "tried to place a muzzle on 'Zeke' but was unsuccessful. Dr. Lacy picked the struggling dog up by the jaws and said: 'I've had enough of this.' The dog began to whine and scream" [wouldn't you whine and scream if somebody picked you up by the jaws?] and the owner thought that "Zeke was biting his tongue. Dr. Lacy then roughly threw the dog onto the exam table and the dog defecated on the table and on Dr. Lacy [and the owner]. At the end of the exam, he told [the owner], 'that dog is psycho."
Um, dude, the DOG IS NOT THE ONE WHO IS PSYCHO!!!!!!
Oh, he called the owner later and apologized for "losing his temper" -- but is there ever an excuse for a veterinarian to lose his temper with an innocent, small, essentially helpless patient?
All that reprehensible behavior and guess what?
The board issued him a letter of INFORMAL REPRIMAND. That's it. No fine, no suspension. Just a slap on the wrist, and not even a "formal" one at that.
The Texas Vet Board sucks!!!
So does Dr. "psycho" Lacy!
Friday, February 15, 2008
Thursday, February 14, 2008
Tail Docking Disgrace
Today's bad vet is Robert White in Idaho.
A breeder of miniature Australian Shepherds took her litter of seven puppies to Dr. Whate in June of 2004. White did the tail-docking procedure on these pups, but later, when the President of the North American Miniature Australian Shepherd club save them, he noted that the tails were too long, and that at that length the dogs would be disqualified from the show ring.
When the owner called Dr. White, he agreed to redo the docks. The owner took five of the puppies back for this second procedure.
The Factual Summary in this case states that Dr. White gave the puppies the sedative xylazine, but did not record the dose, and then used halothane gas as an anesthesia. The board noted that White did not use any pain control medication before, during, or after the tail amputation.
The owner was "shocked when she returned to pick up her pups [and saw] how short the tails were and the severe bleeding that was present. The receptionist told [the owner] to use flour to control the bleeding . . . Also, they did not send any pain medication or e-collars to prevent chewing at the surgical sites by the pups and told [the owner] not to offer food or water until evening."
The owner was not comfortable with these instructions, and took the puppies to another clinic. "The personnel there were shocked at the home care instructions regarding no food or wather for so long in the hot weather with pups at their age . . . they also advised to use 1/2 baby aspirin for pain control . . . "
"Upon further examination . . . [the owner] found that pup #4 had not been shaved in teh area of surgery and that there were only 1-2 very tight sutures in each tail. AT this time they took photos of all the pup's tails . . . The photos depict a very aggressive tail amputation and pup #4 had not been prepared with hair removal . . . . [the owner] took [two of the pups to another veterinarian who] examined the pups and . . felt the tails had been cut to short to be safe for good healing and to avoid potential nerve damage. [The vet] determined there was not enough vital tissue present to close the area and that the infection was a real concern."
The owner had to make several subsequent visits to other vets to get treatment for the puppies, including debriding "necrotic tissue", suturing and wound care, and antibiotic treatments.
The Board, upon review of this case, issued three allegations against Dr. White. In the first allegation (dealing with malpractice or negligence and unprofessional conduct), the Board said "Had Dr. White actually measured the tails and used the anus as a guide for appropriate length, the complications of dehiscence and infection could have been avoided. Having a consent form with a specific description of the exact procedure and lengths of tail detailed could have prevented making the tails so short."
In their second allegation, the board noted that White had "Medical records with no vitals, no history, no plan, no dosages of drugs used, and no concense forms . . . " The cited failure to comply with recordkeeping requirements, unprofessional conduct, and violations of rultes desaling with consent forms.
In the third allegation, the Board noted that "Dr. White did not provide pain control to the pups before, during or after amputation of their tails . . . .Dr. White did not attept to prevent the pps from chewing at their surgical sites by use fo an elizabethan collar. It is reasonable to suspect that pain may have contributed to the puppies chewing on their surgical sites . . . . "
For this allegation the board cited malpractice or negligence and unprofessional conduct.
The Idaho Board put White on probation for a year, ordered him to write a letter of apology to the owners, ordered him to pay a total of $1,475 ($715 to reimburse them for investigatiom costs, and $750 administrative fine); ordered that there would be two unnannounced inspections of his practice in the next year and that White must take a combined total of 10 hours of continuing education in 1) anesthesia, surgery, pain management and aseptic surgical procedres and 2) recordkeeping.
Of all the vet boards I've ever seen, Idaho is the only one that does not suck.
A breeder of miniature Australian Shepherds took her litter of seven puppies to Dr. Whate in June of 2004. White did the tail-docking procedure on these pups, but later, when the President of the North American Miniature Australian Shepherd club save them, he noted that the tails were too long, and that at that length the dogs would be disqualified from the show ring.
When the owner called Dr. White, he agreed to redo the docks. The owner took five of the puppies back for this second procedure.
The Factual Summary in this case states that Dr. White gave the puppies the sedative xylazine, but did not record the dose, and then used halothane gas as an anesthesia. The board noted that White did not use any pain control medication before, during, or after the tail amputation.
The owner was "shocked when she returned to pick up her pups [and saw] how short the tails were and the severe bleeding that was present. The receptionist told [the owner] to use flour to control the bleeding . . . Also, they did not send any pain medication or e-collars to prevent chewing at the surgical sites by the pups and told [the owner] not to offer food or water until evening."
The owner was not comfortable with these instructions, and took the puppies to another clinic. "The personnel there were shocked at the home care instructions regarding no food or wather for so long in the hot weather with pups at their age . . . they also advised to use 1/2 baby aspirin for pain control . . . "
"Upon further examination . . . [the owner] found that pup #4 had not been shaved in teh area of surgery and that there were only 1-2 very tight sutures in each tail. AT this time they took photos of all the pup's tails . . . The photos depict a very aggressive tail amputation and pup #4 had not been prepared with hair removal . . . . [the owner] took [two of the pups to another veterinarian who] examined the pups and . . felt the tails had been cut to short to be safe for good healing and to avoid potential nerve damage. [The vet] determined there was not enough vital tissue present to close the area and that the infection was a real concern."
The owner had to make several subsequent visits to other vets to get treatment for the puppies, including debriding "necrotic tissue", suturing and wound care, and antibiotic treatments.
The Board, upon review of this case, issued three allegations against Dr. White. In the first allegation (dealing with malpractice or negligence and unprofessional conduct), the Board said "Had Dr. White actually measured the tails and used the anus as a guide for appropriate length, the complications of dehiscence and infection could have been avoided. Having a consent form with a specific description of the exact procedure and lengths of tail detailed could have prevented making the tails so short."
In their second allegation, the board noted that White had "Medical records with no vitals, no history, no plan, no dosages of drugs used, and no concense forms . . . " The cited failure to comply with recordkeeping requirements, unprofessional conduct, and violations of rultes desaling with consent forms.
In the third allegation, the Board noted that "Dr. White did not provide pain control to the pups before, during or after amputation of their tails . . . .Dr. White did not attept to prevent the pps from chewing at their surgical sites by use fo an elizabethan collar. It is reasonable to suspect that pain may have contributed to the puppies chewing on their surgical sites . . . . "
For this allegation the board cited malpractice or negligence and unprofessional conduct.
The Idaho Board put White on probation for a year, ordered him to write a letter of apology to the owners, ordered him to pay a total of $1,475 ($715 to reimburse them for investigatiom costs, and $750 administrative fine); ordered that there would be two unnannounced inspections of his practice in the next year and that White must take a combined total of 10 hours of continuing education in 1) anesthesia, surgery, pain management and aseptic surgical procedres and 2) recordkeeping.
Of all the vet boards I've ever seen, Idaho is the only one that does not suck.
Wednesday, February 13, 2008
Diabetic Cat Suffers Cerebral Injury from Hypoglycemia and Hypoxia while in the "Care" of Unlicensed, Unsupervised Staff of Vet Candace Olson
Candace Olson was the Veterinarian-in-Charge at Greenbriar Animal Hospital in Fairfax VA when Dazee, a diabetic cat, was brought in for a medical board by her owner.
At that time, "Dr. Olson . . .represented that she had additional training in the care of diabetic cats," which was one of the reasons the owner selected her.
But Dr. Olson wasn't caring for Dazee -- she left town. Who did she entrust with the care of Dazee? Not her licensed veterinary technician either -- Olson says that the licensed technician was not on duty when Dazee was there. So, we are left to conclude that the "employee" left to care for Dazee was an unlicensed person without formal training.
As you may know, insulin is a life-saving, but potentially very dangerous drug. Exact dosing is very important, and it is also important for those caring for diabetics to know exactly what trouble signs to watch for, and how to deal with emergencies. But apparently, that was not the case here.
A few days after she was left at Greenbriar, an "employee" came in and found Dazee "lying on her side with her head back, and only her legs moving. This employee stated that Dr. Olson failed to leave instructions regarding Dazee's insulin dosage and eating" [the fact that Dazee must eat before getting her shots].
When the employee contacted Dr. Olson she told the employee to take Dazee to Pender Veterinary Clinic. When she arrived Dazee was seizing, although her blood sugar was 66.9 (normal range). The Pender vet consulted with a neurologist and they concluded that Dazee had suffered brain damaged from hypoglycemia and hypoxia. Dazee's owner took her home, but she died a few weeks later.
In the investigation, the Board found that Dazee's blood sugar was never tested before she was given her insulin shots. An insulin overdose could have caused all of the brain damage that Dazee suffered. Moreover, Olson had left Dazee in the care of an unlicensed individual.
Clearly, this is not the level of care Dazee's human loved one was counting on when she selected this self-proclaimed "feline diabetes expert" to care for her cat. And now, Dazee is dead.
So what is appropriate discipline for such an action anyway?
Well, the State Board fined Dr. Olson only $500.
The website of Dr. Olson's clinic, Greenbriar, continues to market its "posh cat boarding" facilities, and also has brochures alleging that they take "special care" and "one-on-one" care for your pet and that their staff are "well-trained." Dr. Olson's profile says that she pays attention to the "smallest details" for your pet. Hmmm, none of this is consistent with what happened to Dazee in her care.
So, what do you believe -- marketing claims, or experience?
Links:
http://www.dhp.virginia.gov/Notices/VetMed/0301002217/0301002217Order09112002.pdf
At that time, "Dr. Olson . . .represented that she had additional training in the care of diabetic cats," which was one of the reasons the owner selected her.
But Dr. Olson wasn't caring for Dazee -- she left town. Who did she entrust with the care of Dazee? Not her licensed veterinary technician either -- Olson says that the licensed technician was not on duty when Dazee was there. So, we are left to conclude that the "employee" left to care for Dazee was an unlicensed person without formal training.
As you may know, insulin is a life-saving, but potentially very dangerous drug. Exact dosing is very important, and it is also important for those caring for diabetics to know exactly what trouble signs to watch for, and how to deal with emergencies. But apparently, that was not the case here.
A few days after she was left at Greenbriar, an "employee" came in and found Dazee "lying on her side with her head back, and only her legs moving. This employee stated that Dr. Olson failed to leave instructions regarding Dazee's insulin dosage and eating" [the fact that Dazee must eat before getting her shots].
When the employee contacted Dr. Olson she told the employee to take Dazee to Pender Veterinary Clinic. When she arrived Dazee was seizing, although her blood sugar was 66.9 (normal range). The Pender vet consulted with a neurologist and they concluded that Dazee had suffered brain damaged from hypoglycemia and hypoxia. Dazee's owner took her home, but she died a few weeks later.
In the investigation, the Board found that Dazee's blood sugar was never tested before she was given her insulin shots. An insulin overdose could have caused all of the brain damage that Dazee suffered. Moreover, Olson had left Dazee in the care of an unlicensed individual.
Clearly, this is not the level of care Dazee's human loved one was counting on when she selected this self-proclaimed "feline diabetes expert" to care for her cat. And now, Dazee is dead.
So what is appropriate discipline for such an action anyway?
Well, the State Board fined Dr. Olson only $500.
The website of Dr. Olson's clinic, Greenbriar, continues to market its "posh cat boarding" facilities, and also has brochures alleging that they take "special care" and "one-on-one" care for your pet and that their staff are "well-trained." Dr. Olson's profile says that she pays attention to the "smallest details" for your pet. Hmmm, none of this is consistent with what happened to Dazee in her care.
So, what do you believe -- marketing claims, or experience?
Links:
http://www.dhp.virginia.gov/Notices/VetMed/0301002217/0301002217Order09112002.pdf
Tuesday, February 12, 2008
After Vet Overinflates Tracheal Tube Balloon, Cat Dies of Conditon that Has Been Associated with Ruptured Trachea
Tonight's bad vet comes from Wisconsin.
The owner brought in a 10-year old boy kitty, who was gagging, "pawing at the throat," and vomiting phlegm.
Vet Carey Johnson did a chest x-ray. The x-ray showed that the cat's stomach was "air filled and displaced behind the diaphragm." The cat also had a "slightly elevated trachea."
Johnson then "administered hydrogen peroxide to induce vomiting which produced only foam." Johnson "then injected ketamine/xylazine and acepromazine to induce vomiting and only a small amount of clear fluid was obtained."
Johnson "did not record the dosage amounts of the drugs administered to the cat in either the controlled substances log or the patient record."
Then, Johnson decided to put an "endotracheal" tube down the cats throat while she did an oral examination.
"During placement of the endotracheal tube, [Johnson] inflated the balloon cuff to the point that rupture of the trachea may have occurred. . . . Subseqent radiographs [xrays] taken by [Johnson] reveal an over inflated balloon cuff. [Johnson] did not recognize the over inflation upon review of the radiograph [xray]."
The cat deveoped a "pneumothorax" and died the next morning.
OK, so you might be wondering: What is a pneumothorax, and did the vet cause this with the overinflation of the tracheal tube, thus perhaps causing the cats death?
PNEUMOTHORAX: WHEN AIR ACCUMULATES BETWEEN THE LUNG AND THE CHEST WALL, CAUSING THE LUNG TO BE COMPRESSED (COLLAPSED), AND CAN COMPROMISE THE HEART FUNCTION LEADING TO POSSIBLE RESPIRATORY OR CARDIAC ARREST. http://www.ctshearts.com/Terminology.asp
What can cause "pneumothorax?"
Check out this abstract in the Annals of Thoracic Surgery:
http://ats.ctsnetjournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/60/5/1367
It says:
"Tracheobronchial rupture after tracheal intubation has been infrequently reported . . . Overinflation of the tracheal cuff was speculated to be a frequent cause of the tracheal damage because the lesion was always a linear laceration of the posterior membranous wall. The diagnosis was suspected on the basis of common signs such as subcutaneous emphysema, respiratory distress, pneumomediastnum and pneumothorax. . . . Tracheal intubation–related airways ruptures are rare but probably underestimated. Early recognition and emergent repair are essential because failure to do so could result in potentially lethal events."
Can you imagine being this poor cat? You are brought into the vet sick, the give you medicine (who knows how much!) to make you puke, then the shove a tube down your throat and inflate it until it "may have" ruptured your bronchial airway? Air leaks around your lungs until your lungs collapse, you can't breathe, and you die?
The Board found that Johnson's "conduct constituted a violation of Wis. Adm. Code Sec. VE 7.06 (1) in that she failed to properly manage the patient’s airway by failing to properly inflate the balloon cuff on the endotracheal tube and that she failed to recognize on subsequent radiograph the over inflation which may have resulted in rupture of the trachea."
They keep saying "may have." But the cat died with pneumothorax, a known complication of overinflating the tracheal tube ballon and thus causing "tracheobronchial rupture." What do you thinkk -- do you think the vet board really knows that this vets actions caused this cat to die? What does it sound like to YOU?
So what punishment did the vet board give this vet? They made her take 7 hours of classes and pay them the investigation costs (only $550). Do you think that's enough?
Links: http://drl.wi.gov/dept/decisions/docs/1204120.htm
http://ats.ctsnetjournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/60/5/1367
http://www.ctshearts.com/Terminology.asp
The owner brought in a 10-year old boy kitty, who was gagging, "pawing at the throat," and vomiting phlegm.
Vet Carey Johnson did a chest x-ray. The x-ray showed that the cat's stomach was "air filled and displaced behind the diaphragm." The cat also had a "slightly elevated trachea."
Johnson then "administered hydrogen peroxide to induce vomiting which produced only foam." Johnson "then injected ketamine/xylazine and acepromazine to induce vomiting and only a small amount of clear fluid was obtained."
Johnson "did not record the dosage amounts of the drugs administered to the cat in either the controlled substances log or the patient record."
Then, Johnson decided to put an "endotracheal" tube down the cats throat while she did an oral examination.
"During placement of the endotracheal tube, [Johnson] inflated the balloon cuff to the point that rupture of the trachea may have occurred. . . . Subseqent radiographs [xrays] taken by [Johnson] reveal an over inflated balloon cuff. [Johnson] did not recognize the over inflation upon review of the radiograph [xray]."
The cat deveoped a "pneumothorax" and died the next morning.
OK, so you might be wondering: What is a pneumothorax, and did the vet cause this with the overinflation of the tracheal tube, thus perhaps causing the cats death?
PNEUMOTHORAX: WHEN AIR ACCUMULATES BETWEEN THE LUNG AND THE CHEST WALL, CAUSING THE LUNG TO BE COMPRESSED (COLLAPSED), AND CAN COMPROMISE THE HEART FUNCTION LEADING TO POSSIBLE RESPIRATORY OR CARDIAC ARREST. http://www.ctshearts.com/Terminology.asp
What can cause "pneumothorax?"
Check out this abstract in the Annals of Thoracic Surgery:
http://ats.ctsnetjournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/60/5/1367
It says:
"Tracheobronchial rupture after tracheal intubation has been infrequently reported . . . Overinflation of the tracheal cuff was speculated to be a frequent cause of the tracheal damage because the lesion was always a linear laceration of the posterior membranous wall. The diagnosis was suspected on the basis of common signs such as subcutaneous emphysema, respiratory distress, pneumomediastnum and pneumothorax. . . . Tracheal intubation–related airways ruptures are rare but probably underestimated. Early recognition and emergent repair are essential because failure to do so could result in potentially lethal events."
Can you imagine being this poor cat? You are brought into the vet sick, the give you medicine (who knows how much!) to make you puke, then the shove a tube down your throat and inflate it until it "may have" ruptured your bronchial airway? Air leaks around your lungs until your lungs collapse, you can't breathe, and you die?
The Board found that Johnson's "conduct constituted a violation of Wis. Adm. Code Sec. VE 7.06 (1) in that she failed to properly manage the patient’s airway by failing to properly inflate the balloon cuff on the endotracheal tube and that she failed to recognize on subsequent radiograph the over inflation which may have resulted in rupture of the trachea."
They keep saying "may have." But the cat died with pneumothorax, a known complication of overinflating the tracheal tube ballon and thus causing "tracheobronchial rupture." What do you thinkk -- do you think the vet board really knows that this vets actions caused this cat to die? What does it sound like to YOU?
So what punishment did the vet board give this vet? They made her take 7 hours of classes and pay them the investigation costs (only $550). Do you think that's enough?
Links: http://drl.wi.gov/dept/decisions/docs/1204120.htm
http://ats.ctsnetjournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/60/5/1367
http://www.ctshearts.com/Terminology.asp
Monday, February 11, 2008
Vermont Vet Paeplow Found to Have Committed Unprofessional Conduct when Cat Left Without Monitoring Dies After Dental
This story is a cautionary tale about what you as a pet owner need to be concerned about when you take your otherwise healthy pet to the vet for a routine procedure like a dental.
Here are excerpts from the Vet Board's Findings in the case of the unnamed cat:
"On or about May 3, 2004 Dr. [John] Paeplow performed a routine dental cleaning on a cat belonging to the complainant, E.H. He began the procedure at around 10:00 am.
The procedure was performed under a general anesthetic. Dr. Paeplow used an injectible anesthetic, Ketamine. One of the effects of this type of drug is hypothermia.
The drug is measured according to the weight of the animal.
He testified that he did not remember where he got the information about the dosage he used. He said it was so long ago he could not remember the origin of information. The Board finds that Dr. Paeplow relied on old information."
[Comment: The Board's focus on the dosage used cannot be for no reason. Where there is smoke, suspect fire. Does the Board infer here that they believe too high a dose may have been given????]
"The recovery room was heated. Dr. Paeoplow could not say if he used a heater for the cat or not.
Dr. Paeplow did monitor the cat until 12:00 noon. At that time the cat appeared to be well on its way to recovering from anesthesia. It had awakened, its eyes were open and its head bobbed. It moved in its cage. It appeared to be recovering normally."
[Comment: Clearly, that is the vet's account. As we will soon see, he then left the office and the cat was not monitored, and the cat died. As a consumer, I have to question whether or not his account of seeing the cat start to recover before he left is true. If he needed excuses for leaving, if there were no witnesses to the contrary, and if he was willing to lie -- he could simply claim that he saw the cat recovering to minimize the appearance of negligence.]
"Dr. Paeplow testified that in his 38 years of practice including thousands of anesthesia administrations, he had not ever seen a cat that had reached the point of recovery he saw in this cat and then fail to fully recover from the anesthesia."
"Dr. Paeplow left his office for lunch with Ms. Marcotte, another employee at the practice.
D.B., a recent hire at the office, was left at the practice."
[Comment: As we will later learn, D.B. is a receptionist -- NOT a veterinary technician.]
"D.B. was not trained in anesthesia monitoring and post procedure monitoring.
While Dr. Paeplow was out of the office, D.B. left the office for an hour and a half, leaving the cat unattended."
"At some time between noon and 2:40 the cat died. The cause of death was not clear. No post mortem was conducted."
"At approximately 2:40 p.m. that day, E.H. [the owner] called Dr. Paeplow's office. The receptionist, D.B., told E.H. that she could come pick up the cat.
E.H. arrived at 2:55 p.m.
D.B. took E.H. back to where the cat was and found it dead.
[Comment: Please note the time. This cat has gone without competent veterinary monitoring for 3 whole hours. Do you think it would have made a difference if someone had given a damn, to check on this cat, to help this cat, to make sure this cat had competent and capable people there to help it???? They might have been able to save it's life, instead it was left without veterinary monitoring and died.]
"This was extremely upsetting for E.H. [owner]. Dr. Paeplow described it as a "horrendous scene."
[Um, are we supposed to feel sorry for these people that the client made a "scene" when the receptionist takes her back to get her cold, dead cat?]
"Dr. Paeplow showed up moments later."
[Comment: What exactly was Dr. Paeplow doing on his lunch with Ms. Marcotte that took 3 hours?????]
"Dr. Paeplow felt the cat and described it as 'cold' and 'stiffening.'
"After this incident Dr. Paeplow consulted with another veterinarian who advised that one should monitor an animal until it is able to stand on it's feet."
[Um, this guy had been practising for 38 years and he didn't know that? How many dead pets haven't we heard about?]
"At the hearing Dr. Paeplow demonstrated remorse for the incident. He took the initiative to reevaluate his office procedures. He took full responsibility for the course of events."
[Well, that's something.]
The Board concluded:
"By leaving the practice before the cat was able to stand on its feet, Dr. Paeplow failed to properly monitor the cat's recovery from anesthetics. He relied on information and used procedures which he admitted were old. This is a failure to conform to the essential standards of acceptable prevailing practice."
"By leaving D.B. [the receptionist] at the practice, when D.B. was not qualified to monitor the cat and its recovery, Dr. Paeplow delegated responsibilities to a person who was not qualified . . . failure to conform to the essential standards of acceptable and prevailing practice.
"This is unprofessional conduct."
Let this story serve as a warning to all pet owners: Even when you think the procedure is routine, otherwise healthy pets die during routine veterinary procedures all the time. If anesthesia is involved, the risk is greater. Please make sure you KNOW EXACTLY WHO will be at the practice when your pet gets a dental or another routine procedure. If needed, physically stay there to make sure they are on top of it. Ask questions about their anesthetic protocol -- who will be monitoring the anesthesia and recovery, what drugs will be used. Get online and ask in veterinary communities if these protocols are standard.
I can tell you that when my cats have dentals, they are given isoflourane and they are intubated to keep their airways open, and are on an IV drip in case something goes wrong and they need to be given some drugs. The veterinary technicians at the place I now use are all licensed. The vet calls me the minute the procedure is done. This is all because I had to learn the hard way. Don't let a story like the one above happen to you or your pet.
Links:
http://vtprofessionals.org/opr1/oprdocs/all/VE12-0504.pdf
Here are excerpts from the Vet Board's Findings in the case of the unnamed cat:
"On or about May 3, 2004 Dr. [John] Paeplow performed a routine dental cleaning on a cat belonging to the complainant, E.H. He began the procedure at around 10:00 am.
The procedure was performed under a general anesthetic. Dr. Paeplow used an injectible anesthetic, Ketamine. One of the effects of this type of drug is hypothermia.
The drug is measured according to the weight of the animal.
He testified that he did not remember where he got the information about the dosage he used. He said it was so long ago he could not remember the origin of information. The Board finds that Dr. Paeplow relied on old information."
[Comment: The Board's focus on the dosage used cannot be for no reason. Where there is smoke, suspect fire. Does the Board infer here that they believe too high a dose may have been given????]
"The recovery room was heated. Dr. Paeoplow could not say if he used a heater for the cat or not.
Dr. Paeplow did monitor the cat until 12:00 noon. At that time the cat appeared to be well on its way to recovering from anesthesia. It had awakened, its eyes were open and its head bobbed. It moved in its cage. It appeared to be recovering normally."
[Comment: Clearly, that is the vet's account. As we will soon see, he then left the office and the cat was not monitored, and the cat died. As a consumer, I have to question whether or not his account of seeing the cat start to recover before he left is true. If he needed excuses for leaving, if there were no witnesses to the contrary, and if he was willing to lie -- he could simply claim that he saw the cat recovering to minimize the appearance of negligence.]
"Dr. Paeplow testified that in his 38 years of practice including thousands of anesthesia administrations, he had not ever seen a cat that had reached the point of recovery he saw in this cat and then fail to fully recover from the anesthesia."
"Dr. Paeplow left his office for lunch with Ms. Marcotte, another employee at the practice.
D.B., a recent hire at the office, was left at the practice."
[Comment: As we will later learn, D.B. is a receptionist -- NOT a veterinary technician.]
"D.B. was not trained in anesthesia monitoring and post procedure monitoring.
While Dr. Paeplow was out of the office, D.B. left the office for an hour and a half, leaving the cat unattended."
"At some time between noon and 2:40 the cat died. The cause of death was not clear. No post mortem was conducted."
"At approximately 2:40 p.m. that day, E.H. [the owner] called Dr. Paeplow's office. The receptionist, D.B., told E.H. that she could come pick up the cat.
E.H. arrived at 2:55 p.m.
D.B. took E.H. back to where the cat was and found it dead.
[Comment: Please note the time. This cat has gone without competent veterinary monitoring for 3 whole hours. Do you think it would have made a difference if someone had given a damn, to check on this cat, to help this cat, to make sure this cat had competent and capable people there to help it???? They might have been able to save it's life, instead it was left without veterinary monitoring and died.]
"This was extremely upsetting for E.H. [owner]. Dr. Paeplow described it as a "horrendous scene."
[Um, are we supposed to feel sorry for these people that the client made a "scene" when the receptionist takes her back to get her cold, dead cat?]
"Dr. Paeplow showed up moments later."
[Comment: What exactly was Dr. Paeplow doing on his lunch with Ms. Marcotte that took 3 hours?????]
"Dr. Paeplow felt the cat and described it as 'cold' and 'stiffening.'
"After this incident Dr. Paeplow consulted with another veterinarian who advised that one should monitor an animal until it is able to stand on it's feet."
[Um, this guy had been practising for 38 years and he didn't know that? How many dead pets haven't we heard about?]
"At the hearing Dr. Paeplow demonstrated remorse for the incident. He took the initiative to reevaluate his office procedures. He took full responsibility for the course of events."
[Well, that's something.]
The Board concluded:
"By leaving the practice before the cat was able to stand on its feet, Dr. Paeplow failed to properly monitor the cat's recovery from anesthetics. He relied on information and used procedures which he admitted were old. This is a failure to conform to the essential standards of acceptable prevailing practice."
"By leaving D.B. [the receptionist] at the practice, when D.B. was not qualified to monitor the cat and its recovery, Dr. Paeplow delegated responsibilities to a person who was not qualified . . . failure to conform to the essential standards of acceptable and prevailing practice.
"This is unprofessional conduct."
Let this story serve as a warning to all pet owners: Even when you think the procedure is routine, otherwise healthy pets die during routine veterinary procedures all the time. If anesthesia is involved, the risk is greater. Please make sure you KNOW EXACTLY WHO will be at the practice when your pet gets a dental or another routine procedure. If needed, physically stay there to make sure they are on top of it. Ask questions about their anesthetic protocol -- who will be monitoring the anesthesia and recovery, what drugs will be used. Get online and ask in veterinary communities if these protocols are standard.
I can tell you that when my cats have dentals, they are given isoflourane and they are intubated to keep their airways open, and are on an IV drip in case something goes wrong and they need to be given some drugs. The veterinary technicians at the place I now use are all licensed. The vet calls me the minute the procedure is done. This is all because I had to learn the hard way. Don't let a story like the one above happen to you or your pet.
Links:
http://vtprofessionals.org/opr1/oprdocs/all/VE12-0504.pdf
Sunday, February 10, 2008
Pug Kodi Dies While in Care of "Hazard"-ous Banfield Vet
We have to stay with South Carolina today, to give an update to a bad vet story that has been on the net for a while.
In 2005, Jennifer Malecki took her beloved purebred pub, Kodi, to the Banfield Veterinary Hospital on Habison Boulevard in Columbia, South Carolina for a vaccine. Ms. Malecki informed the staff there that Kodi had suffered vaccine reactions in the past. Ms. Malecki left Kodi there in the care of veterinarian Angela Hazard.
Approximately 2 hours later Banfield called her to tell her that Kodi was dead.
Ms. Malecki filed a complaint with the Board in 2005, and the Vet Board then issued a formal complaint against Hazard.
In their formal complaint, the Board said:
". . . the allegations, if true, constitute professonal misconduct . . . on information and belief, Respondent has engaged in certain conduct that violates provisions of the South Carolina Veterinary Medicine Practice Act . . . and the rules and regulatons of hte Board, including commission of the following acts and their consequences:
A. On or about March 1, 2005, Respondent provided treatment to a male pug "Kodi" owned by Jennifer Maleki. Respondent had knowledge that the pug has suffered allergic reactions to vaccines in the past. Respondent provided vaccinations consisting of rabies, leptospirosis (4-way), distempter and corona at 9:45. There are no additional documented observations of the animal until 11:30. Respondent failed to document treatment of the patient between 9:45 and 11:30. Respondent further failed to properly monitor the patient subsequent within a reasonable interval after vaccinations of an animal known to suffer allergic reactions to vaccinations."
B. Respondent made attempts to treat the adverse reactions to the vaccinations. Respondent attempted to place an IV catheter. Respondent further provided subcutaneous injections of dexamethasone" [a steroid] "and diphenhydramine" [an antihistamine]. "Respondent did not attempt techniques such as endotracheal intubation" [which, I presume, would have kept Kodi's airway from closing up] "resuscitative medications, chest compressions, intracardiac administration of medications, or CPR. This conduct fails to meet the appropriate standard of care."
In her original response to this complaint, Hazard and her lawyer denied most of it. They called the death of Kodi "an intervening act of God or unavoidable natural occurrence" that was "not the result of any negligence on the part of Dr. Hazard." This was in September, 2006.
However, in April 2007, Hazard signed a consent agreement with the Board, admitting that "she failed to meet the requisite standard of care in her treatment of . . . "Kodi" as alleged in the Formal Complaint . . . "
Was Hazard knowingly lying when she denied responsibility and called the death of Kodi an "act of God?"
It seems evident that although she was told that Kodi had vaccine reactions, Kodi was nonetheless given vaccines and then not monitored for over an hour and a half.
Is that responsible?
Kodi had a reaction. Kodi died. Was that an "act of God" or the act of an irresponsible vet?
One thing I find interesting about the Board decision is that although they name Hazard they don't name the hospital at which this all happened -- Banfield. In some decisions, they do name the hospital. Why not here? Are they trying to protect the big bad corporate giant Banfield? Are they afraid of Banfield?
When a vet does something like this, is the vet alone responsible, or is the management of the veterinary hospital also responsible? After all, the Board notes that there is no evidence Kodi was monitored for over an hour and a half, even though he was known to have vaccine reactions. Who is setting the standards at these places?
Links:
The pet owner's account:
http://www.complaints.com/directory/2005/april/14/17.htm
http://www.petwalk.com/component/option,com_smf/Itemid,71/topic,257.0/
http://www.consumeraffairs.com/pets/banfield.html
http://www.banfieldsucks.net/On-line_Complaints.html
http://www.tundradogsmusic.com/BadVets/Kodi.htm
The Board Decision:
http://www.llr.state.sc.us/POL/Veterinary/Orders/07%20Orders/07MayHazardA.pdf
In 2005, Jennifer Malecki took her beloved purebred pub, Kodi, to the Banfield Veterinary Hospital on Habison Boulevard in Columbia, South Carolina for a vaccine. Ms. Malecki informed the staff there that Kodi had suffered vaccine reactions in the past. Ms. Malecki left Kodi there in the care of veterinarian Angela Hazard.
Approximately 2 hours later Banfield called her to tell her that Kodi was dead.
Ms. Malecki filed a complaint with the Board in 2005, and the Vet Board then issued a formal complaint against Hazard.
In their formal complaint, the Board said:
". . . the allegations, if true, constitute professonal misconduct . . . on information and belief, Respondent has engaged in certain conduct that violates provisions of the South Carolina Veterinary Medicine Practice Act . . . and the rules and regulatons of hte Board, including commission of the following acts and their consequences:
A. On or about March 1, 2005, Respondent provided treatment to a male pug "Kodi" owned by Jennifer Maleki. Respondent had knowledge that the pug has suffered allergic reactions to vaccines in the past. Respondent provided vaccinations consisting of rabies, leptospirosis (4-way), distempter and corona at 9:45. There are no additional documented observations of the animal until 11:30. Respondent failed to document treatment of the patient between 9:45 and 11:30. Respondent further failed to properly monitor the patient subsequent within a reasonable interval after vaccinations of an animal known to suffer allergic reactions to vaccinations."
B. Respondent made attempts to treat the adverse reactions to the vaccinations. Respondent attempted to place an IV catheter. Respondent further provided subcutaneous injections of dexamethasone" [a steroid] "and diphenhydramine" [an antihistamine]. "Respondent did not attempt techniques such as endotracheal intubation" [which, I presume, would have kept Kodi's airway from closing up] "resuscitative medications, chest compressions, intracardiac administration of medications, or CPR. This conduct fails to meet the appropriate standard of care."
In her original response to this complaint, Hazard and her lawyer denied most of it. They called the death of Kodi "an intervening act of God or unavoidable natural occurrence" that was "not the result of any negligence on the part of Dr. Hazard." This was in September, 2006.
However, in April 2007, Hazard signed a consent agreement with the Board, admitting that "she failed to meet the requisite standard of care in her treatment of . . . "Kodi" as alleged in the Formal Complaint . . . "
Was Hazard knowingly lying when she denied responsibility and called the death of Kodi an "act of God?"
It seems evident that although she was told that Kodi had vaccine reactions, Kodi was nonetheless given vaccines and then not monitored for over an hour and a half.
Is that responsible?
Kodi had a reaction. Kodi died. Was that an "act of God" or the act of an irresponsible vet?
One thing I find interesting about the Board decision is that although they name Hazard they don't name the hospital at which this all happened -- Banfield. In some decisions, they do name the hospital. Why not here? Are they trying to protect the big bad corporate giant Banfield? Are they afraid of Banfield?
When a vet does something like this, is the vet alone responsible, or is the management of the veterinary hospital also responsible? After all, the Board notes that there is no evidence Kodi was monitored for over an hour and a half, even though he was known to have vaccine reactions. Who is setting the standards at these places?
Links:
The pet owner's account:
http://www.complaints.com/directory/2005/april/14/17.htm
http://www.petwalk.com/component/option,com_smf/Itemid,71/topic,257.0/
http://www.consumeraffairs.com/pets/banfield.html
http://www.banfieldsucks.net/On-line_Complaints.html
http://www.tundradogsmusic.com/BadVets/Kodi.htm
The Board Decision:
http://www.llr.state.sc.us/POL/Veterinary/Orders/07%20Orders/07MayHazardA.pdf
Saturday, February 9, 2008
South Carolina Vet Cuts Dog's Colon During GDV Surgery
Today's Bad Vet is Jerry Dorsam of South Carolina.
In October 2006 Dorsam signed a "consent" agreement with the Board in which he admitted that "he failed to meet the requisite standard of care in his treatment of "Jake" Lash, an eight (8) year old Bull Mastiff."
Dorsam diagnosed Jake with "gastric dilation and volvulus" -- GDV or "bloat" -- when he was brought into Mt. Pleasant Emergency Veterinary Hospital by his owner in September 2005. The next day he performed surgery on Jake.
Two days later, Jake's owner was concerned by drainage from the wound, took Jake back to Mt. Pleasant. Jake was kept overnight and then was sent to another hospital - Veterinary Surgical Care -- the following morning when Mt. Pleasant Emergency Veterinary Hospital closed.
A vet at the new hospital -- Henri Bianucci -- evaluated Jake and recommended exploratory surgery. It was then that Dr. Dorsam's serious surgical errors became evident.
Dr. Bianucci discovered that Jake's incision was ruptured, that "the colon was lacerated and had the remnants of a mattress suture in it adjacent to and apparently the cause of the laceration, the abdomen was filled with foul smelling effusion, and his spleen had a six (6) - eight (8) centimeter mass at the tail end." Jake went into a cardiac arrest on the table during this surgery and could not be revived.
Dorsam later, in a letter to the board, admitted that he failed to "pexy" Jake's stomach (I looked up that word -- it means surgical fixation of an organ) and that he had "involved" the colon during the procedure. He also admitted that he had inadvertently cut the colon which led to "leakage of the colon fluid into the abdomen, causing diffuse peritonitis. [Dorsam] admits that he failed to make every effort to practice veterinary medicine with the highest regard for the patient."
So, sounds like the vet basically killed this dog, right?
Poor Jake had crap flowing out into his stomach because his colon was cut.
So, how much regard did the Vet Board show the patient?
They fined the vet $500 and made him take some continuing education in surgery. And pay the cost of their investigation. But did they make him lose one day of work? Did they suspend him?
Nope.
In October 2006 Dorsam signed a "consent" agreement with the Board in which he admitted that "he failed to meet the requisite standard of care in his treatment of "Jake" Lash, an eight (8) year old Bull Mastiff."
Dorsam diagnosed Jake with "gastric dilation and volvulus" -- GDV or "bloat" -- when he was brought into Mt. Pleasant Emergency Veterinary Hospital by his owner in September 2005. The next day he performed surgery on Jake.
Two days later, Jake's owner was concerned by drainage from the wound, took Jake back to Mt. Pleasant. Jake was kept overnight and then was sent to another hospital - Veterinary Surgical Care -- the following morning when Mt. Pleasant Emergency Veterinary Hospital closed.
A vet at the new hospital -- Henri Bianucci -- evaluated Jake and recommended exploratory surgery. It was then that Dr. Dorsam's serious surgical errors became evident.
Dr. Bianucci discovered that Jake's incision was ruptured, that "the colon was lacerated and had the remnants of a mattress suture in it adjacent to and apparently the cause of the laceration, the abdomen was filled with foul smelling effusion, and his spleen had a six (6) - eight (8) centimeter mass at the tail end." Jake went into a cardiac arrest on the table during this surgery and could not be revived.
Dorsam later, in a letter to the board, admitted that he failed to "pexy" Jake's stomach (I looked up that word -- it means surgical fixation of an organ) and that he had "involved" the colon during the procedure. He also admitted that he had inadvertently cut the colon which led to "leakage of the colon fluid into the abdomen, causing diffuse peritonitis. [Dorsam] admits that he failed to make every effort to practice veterinary medicine with the highest regard for the patient."
So, sounds like the vet basically killed this dog, right?
Poor Jake had crap flowing out into his stomach because his colon was cut.
So, how much regard did the Vet Board show the patient?
They fined the vet $500 and made him take some continuing education in surgery. And pay the cost of their investigation. But did they make him lose one day of work? Did they suspend him?
Nope.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)