Monday, March 10, 2008

A Case of Diabetic Mismanagement? (Kentucky)

This post is about vets that I think are bad, even though the State Veterinary Board found nothing wrong with what they did. And, it is a good example of the kind of complaints that get dismissed. Moreover, this story strikes close to my heart -- as it is about a diabetic cat.

What is particularly disturbing to me is that it appears to me that this cat -- a diabetic -- was being mismanaged and not properly treated by her primary veterinarian (NOT the veterinarian who the owner filed a complaint against), and that this led to repeated crises (hypoglycemic emergencies for the cat.) Ultimately, the cat was taken to another hospital to be treated for hypoglycemic seizures. According to the allegations, instead of receiving a "bolus" (large infusion) of dextrose (water with sugar in it) to raise her blood sugar, was given only a glucose drip, in spite of a very low blood sugar and severe seizures. [Interestingly, when interviewed by the Board, another vet at this hospital claimed the cat WAS given a bolus, but this is not jiving with other statements or the records.] It seems evident to me that this cat's diabetic emergency was NOT dealt with aggressively enough, possibly therefore leading to much more severe brain damage than would otherwise have occurred. Yet, the Kentucky Board dismissed the case, saying there was "insufficient evidence to warrant disciplinary action." Although the owner filing the complaint was not mad at her primary veterinarian, it seems evident to me that the primary vet's mismanagement of this cat's diabetes in fact created the situation in which these repeated, devastating attacks of hypoglycemic occurred -- ultimately leading to the brain damage that caused the cat to be put to sleep. Here is the story:

The complaint filed by the owner said this:

"I took my cat to [Animal Hospital B because it was clsoe and I could not get to [Animal Hospital A] on Saturday, 10/1/05 at 1pm. She was having a severe reaction to insulin (she is diabetic). I told th evet that she was diabetic and needed to be stablized -- they took her in the back and they told me to call back before they closed at 3, which I did. I was told [vet name blacked out] would phone me later with an update. I got home around 5 and there was a message from the vet to call her, which I did. She said PeeWee was still having seizures (which is not normal at all when I take her to [Animal Hospital A] and that a vet tech would be in at 8 to check her blood and would call me with a status report. At 8:30 a vet tech called and said it was very bad ("critical.") She was still having seizures and her blood sugar was dangerously low."

[Note to reader: This cat has now been seizing with very low blood sugard for 7 and a half hours. This can cause severe brain damage, as it did in my cat who was allowed to keep seizing for hours.]

"I said that I have to come get her and take her to [Animal Hospital A]."

[Note to reader: Animal Hospital A is the place this person usually took her cat, for repeated prior such episodes, where they were apparently able to treat the cat with a bolus infusion of dextrose -- but more on that later.]

"When I got there she led me back to my cat and I said I need to take her NOW! The tech kept stalling saying [vet's name blacked out] will be mad and I need to pay. I don't know how long this went back and forth but to this point my cat had been having seizures for seven hours ad I was not happy. Her blood sugar level was 13."

[Note to reader: normal blood sugar for a cat is 60-150. Readings less than 30 are VERY DANGEROUS and can lead to seizures that cause permanent brain damage.]

"I finally got my VISA card out and gave it to her to keep and told her to give me my cat NOW!!! When I got her to [Animal Hospital A] her temperature was 93 degrees and they even asked me to consider putting her down." [Note to reader: Normal body temperature for a cat is about 102 degress. Severe hypothermia often accompanies severe hypoglycemia.]

"PeeWee would have died at [Animal Hospital B]. [Animal Hospital A] had her semi-conscious and semi-responsive in less than an hour when I got there."

So what is up with this story? Reading through the rest of the record, many things become clear:
PeeWee was in bad shape when she got to Animal Hospital B. The vet, in her response to the complaint, describes PeeWee on admission: ". . . in very bad shape, elderly, hypoglycemic, seizuring, hypothermic, meowing, drooling." Then the vet says that they started a glucose drip. They DO NOT say anything about a bolus of dextrose, which is called for in such severe cases.
[Another vet from this hospital later claimed a bolus was given, but this contradicts other statements and the records.]

This vet also notes that the owner reported to him that PeeWee had prior incidents like this since she had her dose of Lente insulin increased.

In the Board's interview with the owner who filed the complaint, the owner said that when she had taken PeeWee to her regular vet for hypoglycemic emergencies the vet "would give her a bolus of sugar IV and she would respond in an hour or so." [Note: A bolus is a larger amount delivered at once, rather than a slow drip.]

This raises a very important question: WHY was PeeWee in repeated crisis? What was wrong with PeeWee's primary treatment regimen -- prescribed by her vet -- that had her in a state where she was having repeated hypoglycemic emergencies?

In the course of the investigation, the veterinary board got a statement from the regular vet. One thing to remember is that the REGULAR vets are the people who had recently increased PeeWee's insulin dose.

The regular vet said that when PeeWee was rushed to them after the owner retrieved her from Animal Hospital B, her glucose was still less than 20 and she was in a coma. She said that PeeWee was "overhydrated" and had a bag of Lactated Ringers solution attached to her leg from Animal Hospital B. [Note: Lactated Ringers does not have ANY sugar in it -- which is what PeeWee needed]

[Another vet also attested that when PeeWee was brought into Animal Hospital A, "She had a catheter in place and a bag of fluids attached to it. The bag was labeled Lactated Ringers Solution, so I assume that is what was in the bag. There was no writing on the bag indicating glucose had been added, so I assume no glucose was in the fluids." [Note to reader: This statement raises questions about whether PeeWee got ANY needed glucose AT ALL at Hospital B!!!!] The vet adds: "There was approximately 300cc's of fluid left in the bag, so I assume 700 cc's had been given." This is a HUGE amount of fluids to give to a cat, and the vet notes that the cat was "overhydrated."

In her statements, regular vet ffom hospital A said: "We changed the fluids to Normal Ringers with 5% dextrose and gave her a bolus of 25% dextrose . . . at midnight [two hours after she was brought in] the glucose was still less than 20. We gave her another bolus of Dextrose and by 4:00am she was eating ravenously. Her glucose was still only 30."

The owner took PeeWee home the next day, only to have to return with her the following day, saying PeeWee had "collapsed." This time, PeeWee's blood sugard was 599. The vet did discharge PeeWee in the evening after giving her fluids and insulin "with the understanding to check the glucose four to six hours post insulin for two days."

This is what I find so disturbing. While it is good the vet talked to the owner about hometesting in this circumstance, blood sugar testing on a diabetic cat shoud be done at the time the shot is given -- not just many hours later -- and it shoudl be done EVERY day, not just after emergencies. Moreover, Lente insulin is a humulin insulin -- not one of the better insulin for cats.

The vet goes on to say:

"[PeeWee] returned on October 8th with a glucose of less than 20. We gave her a bolus of dextrose and put her on Normasol. By 4:00 pm the glucose was 30. The owner took the cat home at 8:30 that night . . . on the 16th she returned with the cat not eating and dry heaving. The glucose was 686. The owner okayed treatment for 24 to 48 hours to see if she improved. By 11:00pm there was no improvement and the owner elected to euthanize her."

Now, here is the good example of how vets stick together, protect each other, and blame their clients for everything:

"The owner had trouble leaving the cat with us long enough to stablize her initially. Who knows if the cat would have responded if she had received a bolus of glucose at Dr. [vet's name blacked out -- vet from Animal Hospital B]. She had brittle diabetes and age against her."

These statements outrage me as someone who has cared for three diabetic cats. It is clear to ME that this veterinarian, from "Animal Hospital A" -- the main veterinarian, was not adequately managing this cats diabetes in the first place, therefore the cat was in a state of chronic crisis. In spite of these repeated episodes of brain-damaging hypoglycemia and life-threatenig hypERglycemia, this vet does not make ONE mention of re-evaluating her patient's insulin protocol, diet, or home monitoring. She just blames the cats failure to do better on "brittle" diabetes and "age."

This is unconscionable in my opinion, and the statements of a delusional vet who is failing to take responsibility for her lousy protocol that is endangering, repeatedly, this patient's life. There are MANY things she could have done -- and did not do -- to help this owner help this cat.

1. Change to another type of insulin. In recent years it has become evident that Humulin insulins -- like "Lente" -- the insulin this cat was on -- are rarely the best choices in cats. Many other insulins are available, specifically both PZI insulin and Glargine (also known as lantus) are longer acting than lente and less harsh in the cat, resulting in a flatter curve and providing better regulation. In spite of the repeated trouble this patient of hers was having, it seems at NO time did this veterinarian question her own protocol -- including the insulin. To my mind, this is outrageously irresponsible.

2. Counsel the owner to implement dietary changes that improve diabetic control. It does not say in these records what food the cat was eating, but it is also well known that diabetic cats should be on a diet of low-carb canned food. This helps avoid the highs and lows that PeeWee experienced. I highly doubt this (in my opinion LAZY) vet was doing that.

3. Counsel the owner to TEST THE CATS BLOOD SUGAR before EVERY shot, ALL the time -- not just spot checks in the 2 days after a crisis. This cat clearly needed closer monitoring and management at home -- the owner would have no way of knowing this. The veterinarian should have counseled the owner to test PeeWee's blood sugar before every shot, and also whenever possible mid-cycle, every day. This poor cat could have been receiving shots of insulin when her blood sugar was already too low to need it. No doctor would advise a human client to inject insulin into himself without testing his blood sugar first -- to do that is highly dangerous. But owners don't know that unless vets tell them.

It seems evident to me that this cat's diabetes was being chronically mismanaged by her original vet, and then she received inadequate treatment in a hypoglycemic crisis which allowed brain damage to occur.

Do you want to know how to save your cat from such tragedy if he or she should become diabetic?

The best thing you can do is to join an online community dedicated to caring for diabetic pets. There are two out there that I would recommend:

http://www.felinediabetes.com/
http://yourdiabeticcat.com/

The members of these lists -- conscientious owners of diabetic pets themselves -- will counsel you on how to hometest you cats blood sugar, and have a wealth of information on insulins and diet. Much of this information is taken DIRECTLY from the most current, cutting edge thinking in diabetic care, which unfortunately, many vets are not up on.

Sunday, March 9, 2008

When Vets Leave Objects in Your Pet During Surgery

In Maryand, veterinarian Benjamin Harman, a veterinarian at Hillside Animal Hospital in Eckart Maryland, left gauze in his patient's abdomen after performing surgery.

http://www.mda.state.md.us/article.php?i=8502

Thursday, March 6, 2008

Washington Vet Loses Bambee, the Italian Greyhound: She is Later Found Dead in a Field

Like many families, to the Lind's, their dog Bambee was more than a pet -- she was a member of the family. The Lind's purchased Bambee, an Italian Greyhound, from a breeder in Salem Oregon in 2005. As told by well-known animal lawyer Adam Karp: "They . . . instantly fell in love with her. Although Mr. Lind cared for dogs throughout his life, he never had a dog that responded to him like Bambee. . . . [Bambee] slept on their pillow in bed almost every night."

The Linds, who ran concessions, travelled regionally for work. They took Bambee with them, getting rooms at pet-friendly motels so that Bambee could be with them. They arranged their schedules so that one of them would be at the hotel with Bambee while the other was working.

One night, however, both the Linds needed to attend an important work-related event. So, for one night, they arranged to board Bambee at Airport West Animal Clinic in Yakima, Washington, where she had previously been seen. Although they had other options (a friend willing to watch Bambee) they thought that Bambee would be safer in the hands of professionals. s

Ten-pound Bambee was very nervous and skittish. According to Karp:

"Former employee Heidi Billings notes that Bambee was 'extremely skittish' at the time she removed her from the cage, and that though she asked co-worker Katie Bombard whether she should leash walk Bambee in the outside enclosure, Ms. Bombard responded in the negative, saying it was 'no big deal.' Ms. Billings was unable to capture Bambee who, predictably, avoided her when approached and escaped through a 3-inch opening in the space of a few seconds."

This occured in spite of the fact that:

  • A few weeks earlier a client had warned the clinic that this opening posed a risk for the escape of her small dog -- a chihuahua -- and instructed the staff to walk her pet on a leash at all times.
  • It was reportedly the practice at the clinic to use a leash with animals who were skittish and small, but this was not done on that day with Bambee
The Linds began a frantic search for Bambee that lasted nearly a week. In the local newspaper, Mr. Lind was quoted as saying "I'm desperate. I love this dog." The Linds even hired International K-9 Search and Rescue Services.

Sadly, "Bambee was found frozen and half-eaten in a field near the clinic. Describing what Mr. Lind saw when he was called to the scene where Bambee had been found, Karp says: "Bambee lay deceased in the field with her insides eaten out. She was still wearing the sweater the Linds had given her. She had no collar, harness, or leash on. "

Reportedly, when Lind went with Bambee's body to Airport West Animal Clinic, to show them what had become of her: "Dr. Erika Kieser allegedly coldly refused to come out, remarking that she had seen dead dogs before."

The Lind's expert witness in their lawsuit against Airport West said that the clinic had violated the standard of care for a boarding facility in several respects. One of these respects was the failure to create proper perimeter fencing for small breeds, such as the Italian Greyhound. She testified that a run or enclosure appropriate for small dogs would have no opening larger than 1 inch. The 3-inch opening in the fence was clearly large enough for a small dog to get through.

Ultimately, the Linds were awarded $6,722.50 plus costs of $650. $5,000 of the award was for the "intrinsic value" of Bambee.

But of course, no amount of money will make the loss of Bambee OK.

Rest in peace, Bambee.

As for Airport West Animal Clinic, the question their current and future clients should ask themselves is: If they were this careless once, is that a way of doing business there? How do you know they aren't equally careless in dozens of other ways?

Beware. And Be Aware.

Links:

www.wsba.org/lawyers/groups/animallaw/animallawoctober2007vol.6no.1.pdf

Wednesday, March 5, 2008

Poor, Poor Georgia Piggy, R.I.P.

This is the story of how a "euthanasia" that was to be performed by Georgia veterinarian Ronald Martin ended in the horrific drowning of a conscious, squealing, struggling pet pig named "Ren."

The Georgia Vet Board's document says:

"On or about December 2, 2004, [Martin] was asked to euthanize "Ren", a Vietnamese Pot-Bellied pig that had been kept as a pet for twelve years but had stopped eating or leaving the house and appeared to be in pain. Respondent went to the owner's home to perform the procedure."

"According to his records, [Martin] injected 10.6 ml of Ketaset subcutaneously. The pig was dissociated, but not generally anesthetized. [Martin] then attempted to inject a euthanasia solution intravenously in five or more sites for a total of 136 ml. When [Martin] ran out of the solution, however, the pig was still alive."

[Martin] "then told the owner he could drown the pig in a bucket of water. [Martin], the owner and a neighbor held the pig down in the water while the pig struggled, squealed and kicked. The pig drowned a few minutes later."

The Board reviewer found that Martin's actions constituted cruelty to Ren, saying:

"Subcutaneous injection of a ketamine solution, as indicated in [Martin's] records, is an incorrect route of administration."

"[Martin's] attempts to inject the euthanasia solution intra-venously failed to meet minimum standards for performing vena-puncture."

[The documents do not provide any details on how those "attempts" may have been botched, why he had to try so many times, or why he messed up performing the "vena-puncture."]

"Drowning is not an acceptable method of euthanizing an animal, and further it is cruel and inhumane. It is beneath the standard of care for a veterinarian to initiate or assist such an act, or to observe it without objection."

The Board fined Martin $1,000, ordered him to take only 5 hours of continuing education in large animal procedure, and gave him a public reprimand. No suspension.

It makes me so very sad to think what poor Ren suffered in his final moments. R.I.P., poor Ren.

Tuesday, March 4, 2008

Dog Dies 5 Hours After Spay

Texas Vet Joe Bennett performed a spay procedure on Ramsy, a Rottweiler. Later that day, Ramsy died less than 5 hours after being picked up by her family. Dr. Bennett had never offered, or performed, pre-surgical bloodwork on Ramsy. During the investigatin, Dr. Bennett stated that during surgery, he noticed that Ramsy had an enlarged spleen, anemia, and had petechia in her abdomen. In the record he had written, "possible ehrlichia." Yet he never informed Ramsy's family of Ramsy's condition, did no bloodwork, and did not discuss the option of seeking care at an emergency clinic with Ramsy's family. As stated above, Ramsy died within 5 hours of being released.

The Texas Vet Board found him in violation of the Professional Standard of Humane Treatment and regulations related to Patient Record-Keeping.

Links to disciplinary file/information:

http://www.thetooncesproject.com/images/TX_2005_Bennett_Joe_2005-36.pdf
http://www.tbvme.state.tx.us/Board%20Minutes/Minutes_6_9_05.pdf

Monday, March 3, 2008

Cat Stabbed in the Heart with Euth Needle by Knife River Vet Edward Foeltz

Did infamous Tennesee veterinarian William Baber have an evil twin practising in North Dakota? An evil twin who has now moved to ply his trade in Minnesota? Interesting how these bad vets get disciplined in one state and then move to another, isn't it -- just like yesterday's bad vet.

Readers should remember the story of Tennessee vet William Baber, who is facing 12 criminal counts including four counts of cruelty to animals, based on his illegal use of "intracardiac injections" as a method of euthanizing -- no, we must say, killing -- shelter animals. These animals were NOT unconscious -- they had been given no drugs for sedation or pain -- prior to Baber shoving the needle into their heart. Reportedly, many dogs struggled and howled and cried as this was done to them.

In the following Veterinary Practice News Article, one vet said: "A decent veterinarian wouldn’t want to perform intracardiac euthanasias unless the animal was in a comatose or anesthetized state."

So it came as a surprise to me to read about Edward Foeltz in North Dakota -- and the harrowing story of how he used "intracardiac injection" -- also called a "heart punch" -- to kill a client's cat. Moreover, it is entirely shocking to me that the outcome of this Board complaint was merely one year of probation, and the order to provie the Board with a "written protocol for in-room euthanasia with the owner present . . . " as though the ONLY thing wrong with how he euthanized the cat was the fact that the owner was present.

In North Dakota, when disciplinary action is taken, both the complaint and the vets response become public record. Below, I excerpt from the owner's complaint, and from the vet's response.

[Cautionary note: The owners complaint should be understood to consist of allegations, which are at the time of the compaint unproven. The vet's response likewise is a defensive claim filled with information that may not be proven or provable. There are, however, many facts in this case about which both the owner and the vet, Foeltz', agree. I will point these out.]

In her complaint, the owner recounted the day that she took her beloved 16 year-old Tuxedo cat, Toby, to Dr. Foeltz at Knife River Veterinary Clinic in Beulah, North Dakota, to be euthanized.

In her complaint she said:

"Dr. Foeltz and his assistant proceed to hold Toby down . . . [I] noticed that Dr. Foeltz was feeling around for his heart. I put my face on Toby's cheek and closed my eyes that's when Dr. Foeltz must have inserted the needle because Toby meowed in pain . . . After several minutes Toby meowed again so I looked up and to my horror I saw the syringe was still in his chest moving freely about! Dr. Foeltz was still feeling around for Toby's heart. I said "I didn't know it was done this way, I thought you went in his leg." Dr. Foetz said, 'Veins are so hard to find and they move around. ' So I just closed my eyes again and kept rubbing and talking to Toby. Toby meowed again when Dr. Foelt was still feeling around for his hear. It was when Toby meowed for hte third time that I no loger could stand hearing him cry out in pain and not be able to do anything about it, so I told them I had to leave. I knew that if I stayed I'd end up stopping the procedure and that would be a mistake to let Toby suffer even more."

"The lobby offered me no comfort as I heart Toby meow two more times. Each meow sounded worse. It was one of the saddest days of my life.

"Dr. Foeltz's assistant finally came out and told me I could come back in. Toby was lying on the table with his eyes clsoed, breathing very heavy. I asked if I could hold him, she said "Yes" and left me with him." Yet, she said, at no time did he use a stethoscope to verify that his heart had stopped.

The owner then recounts that Foeltz came back in and reassured her that Toby was dead. So she took Toby out to the car, and drove home to get her checkbook to pay the vet, as they had told her they didn't take credit cards.

When she arrived home, she said, her husband looked into the truck and Toby, and saw that he was still breathing. So she had to take him back to the clinic -- and ore than a half hour after the original horrifying procedure, another vet -- named Woodruff -- told her that Toby was "in a deep, deep, sleep." This vet administered additional doses to Toby (she does not say how they were administered).

The owner claims that although Woodruff apologized to her for what had happened she also "chuckled."

The owner said that she subsequently consulted with other veterinarians who told her that using a heart shot should ONLY be a last resort, and that it should be done only after sedative is given. This is consitent, by the way, with remarks made about the Baber case.

The vet's response to this complaint was written in one long page and a half with no paragraph breaks. In his response, Foeltz claimed that Toby was "unresponsive" when he went to euthanize him. He said: "Toby was the fourth cat I had to euthanise in the three months of practice I had at the time." [WHAT????? THEY ARE STILL TEACHING THIS BARBARIC TECHNIQE IN VET SCHOOL???]

Explaining why he gave Toby an injection into his heart, he said: "Toby was very unresponsive so I felt the quickest, least painful, and most companionate way to euthanize him was to put 1 cc of euthanasia solution directly into his heart. This was because of his physicial state I didn't feel that using a leg vein would be possible, but that is the way I prefer to euthanise animals."

He said, affirming some of the complainants account: "I did insert the needle and he did meow, but he didn't move and he was only being restrained minimally."

Gee whiz dude, when you are so sick you can't move, what if the nursing home staff restrain you "minimally" when they stick a needle in your heart while you are fully conscious and sort of ignore your cries. How would that be for you?

Foeltz does not address the client's claims that he repeatedly searched around for the heart with this needle. He says:

"I drew back on the syringe and got a flash of blood back into the syringe and then injected the euthanasia solutioin. He did meow again when the solution went into the heart, but at no point during the procedure did he move."

WELL DUH!!! PEOPLE -- AND ANIMALS -- WHO CAN'T MOVE CAN STILL FEEL PAIN, AND YOU AND YOUR ASSISTANT WERE HOLDING HIM, A-HOLE!!!

Foeltz claims that he returned to the room and used a stethoscope to listen for a heartbeat. This version of events is contradicted by the client. He claims he didn't hear a heart beat.

He acknowledges that Toby was taken from the practice and then later returned still alive, in a "deep sleep" at which time "2 more cc's of solution was administered to Toby, through two 1 cc injections to finally make his heart stop."

Foeltz continued to stand by heart shots as an acceptable method of euthanasia for "highly unresponsive cats." Several things are disturbing about this statement. First of all, when a being is VERY ill, they can be unresponsive but still feel pain. The inability to move does not correlate with the inability to feel pain. Second, MEOWING IS A RESPONSE. A cat that meows with pain is not unresponsive. Third, he says "cats." What -- does he have some particular loathing for cats that he reserves this special method of killing only for them? What a peach of a guy he is!

More insight into this man's psyche is evident in his comments about the client. Describing a conversation he had with her in which says he apologized to her "for her loss and for what she experienced" [get that? Not apologizing for what he DID. Apologizing for her LOSS], he said that "She was les then [sic] receptive to the apology and just wanted to vent her anger."

Foeltz also said: "I also have been at the clinic long enough that I can chose [sic] if I want an owner present during the euthanasia. In this case I wouldn't have allowed Miss [x] to be in the room during the procedure due to her state of mind."

BLAMING THE VICTIM!!!! OVER AND OVER that's what this narcissistic freaks do -- no responsibility for their behavior. The problem is NOT how he killed her cat, but rather her "state of mind" and the fact that he ALLOWED her to be present during her beloved 16-year old pets euthanasia.

He goes on to say: "I admit that in this case I made a bad assumption that 1 cc of euthanasia solution would be enough to euthanise Toby, but I should have made Miss [x] put him on the exam table so I could listen to his heart better, no matter how much [she] refused." Keep in mind dear reader, that the client's account of what happened DOES NOT include her refusal to put Toby on an exam table. He adds: "Since Toby I have unfortunately had to euthanise many of peoples beloved pets and haven't had the problems I had with Miss [X] [the owner of Toby]".

Get a load of this freak! He had problems with Miss [x], the owner of Toby -- she's a problem client, rather than him being incompetent and cruel! What a psycho!

Foeltz does say that he will in the future use xylazine as a sedative before giving heart shots in the future "if I feel the best way to euthanize a cat is by injection into their heart." As though it's HIS choice. He also speaks of CHOOSING himself whether or not to ALLOW owers to be with their pets. I guess he figures there will be no one to witness his cruelty. And why are cats repeatedly singled out for this treatment?

In her letter to the Board, the owner said: "I still find myself crying, not just because Toby is gone, but at the HORRER of his last hour of life. He was SUCH a WONDERFUL companion ad friend. I can't stress enough how much love, laughter, & companionship he brought to my familly and me . . . There is not enough paper in the world or words in any language that could ever express how much he is loved and the terrible sadness that still lingers in our hearts."

She closed her letter with a plea to the veterinary board:

" . . . going directly into the heart without sedation is EXTREMELY CRUEL! PLEASE!!!!! DO NOT let another animal be subjected to the torture our Toby endured."

Well, dear lady, sadly, nothing the vet board did in this case will prevent this from happening again. With their emphasis on Foeltz having to come up with "a written protocol for in-room euthanasia with the owner present that meets the minimum standards of practice," they imply that the only thing wrong with what he did to Toby is that he let you witness it. And, they also imply that minimum standards of practice apply only when there is someone there to witness the veterinarian's actions.

Foeltz has said he will continue his heart punch method when he sees fit, and it seems to be specially reserved for kitties. Although he now says he will sedate them first -- with xylazine.

About that xylazine, is it another sadistic plan?

According to this: http://www.ccac.ca/en/CCAC_Programs/ETCC/Module10/xylazine.html cats and dogs may vomit soon after the administration of xylazine. The vets I know now use telazol which does not do this. Moreover the following article says that the use of xylazine alone as a pre-euthanasia sedative leaves the animals "seemingly conscious and aware of pain."

http://www.examiner.com/a-1230689~Bill_could_make_euthanasia_less_painful_for_animals.html

One poster in response to this article added: "I work in an animal shelter and xylazine does NOT offer a humane way of putting animals to sleep. Many cats go into seizures . . . "

So, Foeltz plan for preventing horror scenes like the one that occurred with Toby is that prior to injecting them in the heart, he's going to give them a shot that makes them puke, gives them seizures, and leaves them conscious and aware of pain?

Is he a freakin SADIST?

This article -- sadly from my state of Maryland, describes the horrific scenes that are ensuing now at Maryland shelters as xylazine is being used in place of ketamine. http://www.hometownannapolis.com/cgi-bin/readne/2008/02_03-24/TOP "The xlayzine leaves animals woozy and desensitized, but "clearly you can tell the animal still knows what's going on . . . we don't know if we can prevent convulsions in the animal "

As for the overall practice of intracardiac injections, the Humane Society of the United States has said in its guidelines on shelter medicine:

"Intracardiac (IC) injections (into one of the four chambers of the heart) are acceptable only for animals who have been verified as unconscious. An injection into a conscious animal’s chest is stressful and extremely painful and therefore considered to be cruel."

http://www.animalsheltering.org/resource_library/policies_and_guidelines/statement_on_euthanasia.html

Also, NIH guidelines for euthanasia of lab animals also state that intra-cardiac injections are "acceptable only when performed on heavily sedated, anesthetized, or comatose animals."
http://www.iacuc.msu.edu/iacuc/policies_and_guidelines/euthanasia%20guidelines.pdf

Which, Toby clearly was not.

The Vermont Department of Agriculture states that: "At no time shall intracardiac injections be used on conscious animals."

Similar explicit restrictions are in place at universities nationwide.

Furthermore, the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) euthanasia guidelines state:

"Intracardiac injection is acceptable only when performed on heavily sedated, anesthetized, or comatose animals. It is not considered acceptable in awake animals, owing to the difficulty and unpredictability of performing the injection accurately."

In the State of North Dakota, Veterinarians are "immune from liability" under animal cruelty laws. So even though Foeltz' actions were -- by definitions of many accepted guidelines -- inhumane, and at first blush, it may seem that Toby's humans would have a good basis for animal cruelty charges -- in the State of North Dakota, like about half of the states in the U.S. -- veterinarians are "immune to prosecution" under animal cruelty statutes.

ALERT: As of July 2007, Foeltz had been issued a "conditional license" to practice in Minnesota. Minnesota Pet Parents, BEWARE!

http://www.vetmed.state.mn.us/portals/22/FoeltzOrder.pdf

Sunday, March 2, 2008

Minnesota Vet's License Finally Revoked after Horrifying, Long Track Record Regarding his Treatment of Both Pet Patients and Human Colleagues

The case of Todd Varnes provides a heartbreaking example of the many additional victims whose wellbeing and very lives are placed in jeapardy when veterinary boards allow vets who are known to be dangerous to continue practising.

From 1991 through 2004, veterinarian Todd Varnes has held veterinary licenses in Georgia, Wisconsin, Illinois, Indiana, and Minnesota.

In 2000, the Indiana Veterinary Board placed Varnes' license on indefinite suspension after issuing the following Findings of Fact:

"On January 13, 1996, [Varnes] undertook the care and treatment of patient N, a female canine that eight days earlier had undergone an ovariohysterectomy." (Spay.)

"Patient N presented with a history of recent bleeding and passing fluid from the area of the incision, including passing blood clots in the urine.

"[Varnes] diagnosed N with a urinary tract infection based on urinalysis findings. [Varnes] did not obtain a blood cell count to verify the presence of infection"

"[Varnes] failed to properly and adequately diagnose the condition of patient N . . . "

"[Varnes] failed to properly and adequately treat the suspected urinary tract infection, including but not limiting to prescribing an inadequate dosage of antibiotics."

"On September 8, 1996, [Varnes] undertook the care and treatment of patient B.B., a male feline suffering from multiple traumatic injuries."

"[Varnes] performed emergency surgery on B.B. on September 8, 1996."

"[Varnes] failed to adequately assess and repair the traumatic injuries to B.B. during surgery, including but not limited to failure to reestablish connective tissue and musculature continuity in areas where it had been torn from the rectum, anus, and penis."

[Comment: What is this cat doing with traumatic injuries to his rectum, anus, and penis? Would that not raise a flag to you?]

"[Varnes] failed to properly and adequately assess and diagnose B.B. for severe internal injuries sustained as a result of trauma, including but not limited to chest contusions, trauma to the mediastinum and cardiac system, and extensive bilateral lung trauma."

"In his care and treatment of B.B., [Varnes] failed to obtain radiology testing to assess and evaluate the patient's severe traumatic injuries." (That means he didn't take x-rays.)

"[Varnes] released B.B. to home on the day of the surgery, although the animal was unstable and in need of postoperative monitoring."

"[Varnes] assured B.B.'s owner that the animal was safely 'out of the woods' and failed to provide adequate instructions for monitoring and follow-up care."

"As a result of [Varnes] conduct described above, B.B. suffered unnecessarily and subsequently died on September 9, 1996."

"On November 14, 1996 [Varnes] was charged with the responsibility of the supervision of The Pet Practice, a 24 hour emergency animal hospital clinic located at 4030 West 86th Street, Indianapolis, Indiana."

"[Varnes] left the clinic at approximately 1:00 a.m. on November 14, 1996. [Varnes] did not return to the clinic during his shift."

"The veterinary technician assigned to work the night shift with [Varnes] on November 14 was a new employee on her first shift of work for The Pet Practice. The technician, S.E., was untrained and unfamiliar with this specific facility, and had not been oriented to the layout, policies, or procedures specific to The Pet Practice."

"[Varnes] was contacted by S.E. at approximately 6:00 a.m. on November 14, 1996, and given a report regarding an emergency patient who had presented for treatment."

"[Varnes] replied that he could not be present in the clinic in less than one hour's time to treat the animal reported to him by S.E."

The Board found Varnes in violation of statutes related to failure to supervise staff, failure to "exercise the reasonable care and diligence ordinarily exercised by members of his profession," and stated that he had become "unfit to practice due to failure to keep abreast of current professional theory or practice."

They indefinitely suspended his license.

So, what does Varnes do?

He begins practising in Minnesota, where, as of March 2004, the Board there had also launched an investigation against him.

I am beginning to get a clue as to why this guy may have licenses in FIVE states.

A public record available online from the State of Minnesota makes it clear that the actions described above were not the only complaints people had about Dr. Varnes while he was practicing in Indiana. The Minnesota document, available here:

http://www.vetmed.state.mn.us/portals/22/Varnes.pdf

Says that Varnes' "file from the Indiana veterinary practice contains negative information about Licensee's conduct, including statements that licensee failed to follow clinic policy by refusing to attend to certain patients; that the Indiana practice received numerous complaints from staff and clients regarding Licensee's treatment of them; and that Licensee handled an aggressive dog unnecessarily roughly; that Licensee, while in a fit of temper, threw all of the articles from a desk on the floor, cursed loudly enough that the clients in the lobby heard him and called one of the staff members a vulgar name."

So, how did Varnes behave when he moved to Minnesota?

The Minnesota Board said:

"The Board received complaints about [Varnes'] conduct while in practice at Affordacare Veterinary Clinic in Blaine, Minnesota. The complaints included allegations that [Varnes]:

Was unable to control his anger, became angry during his treatment of animals, and had fits of rage during which he screamed, threw objects, cursed, slammed doors, and left the clinic to drive around while animals were still under anesthesia;

Engaged in threatening and abusive conduct toward clinic staff;

Used profanity and made vulgar statements and statements of a sexual nature to female staff;

Engaged in abusive conduct toward animals, including being unnecessarily rough when moving animals, throwing animals or squeezing their limbs, and screaming at animals;

Performed declaw procedures on cats that were not fully anesthetized;

Failed to use a pulse oximeter during all surgeries when prevailing standards of practice would require the use of a pulse oximeter, including in the case of a dog that died after [Varnes'] veterinary technician failed to properly place an endotracheal tube and [Varnes] failed to check the endotracheal tube to ensure it was properly inserted;"

[Note: the endotracheal tube keeps the animal's airway open while they are anesthetized']

"Failed to render appropriate care to a sixteen year-old dog that had trouble breathing following dental extractions;

"Directed unlicensed veterinary technicians to extract animals' teeth, which constitutes unlicensed practice of veterinary medicine;

"Failed to maintain sterile packs for each set of surgical instruments and did not consistenly wear a gown, mask, or head covering during surgery; and

"Failed to comply with state and federal regulations regardign the maintenance of controlled substance records and inventory."

PHEW!!!! But get this -- it goes on to say:

"In connection with the [Minnesota] complaint review Committee's investigation of the complaints against him, [Varnes] voluntarily underwent a multidisciplinary assessement at Rush Behavioral Center in Downers Grove, Illinois. The evaluators diagnosed [Varnes] as having a personality disorder not otherwise specified with narcissistic and schizoid features . . . "

BUT GET THIS!!!! IN SPITE OF ALL OF THIS, the Minnesota Vet Board allowed Varnes to continue practising -- and continue treating Minnesota's pets on a "conditional" license. The conditions, being basically that he participate in specified mental health counseling, and well - stop behaving the way he had been behaving.

These conditions were placed on his license in Marcy 2004, and in September 2004 the Minnesota Board finally revoked his license after he continued racking up new violations so heinous that they boggle the mind. Frankly, it seems that Varnes was thumbing his nose at the Vet Board and the world.

In September 2004, the Vet Board found that between March 31, 2004 and September 1, 2004, Varnes did the following things while practising at a clinic he owns in Blaine, Minnesota:

". . . employed abusive language directed at clinic staff and other veterinarians . . . "

". . . made degrading or demeaning comments . . . including calling female staff 'worthless broads' . . . and criticizing the veterinarian's surgeries in front of other staff" (HA! He's got his nerve!)

" . . . was very angry exiting an examination room and knocked a receptionist into a hallway wall"

". . . threw objects . . . "

" . . . authorized veterinary technicians to perform dental extractions and give diagnoses over the telephone . . . "

Violations related to drug storage and recordkeeping related to drugs

Also, according to signed affidavits from veterinarians and veterinary technicians, he:

"[Varnes] masked down dogs and cats for anesthesia isoflurane alone without any pre-anesthetic, causing many of the animals to struggle, whine, urinate, defecate or express their anal glands while the gas anesthesia was being administered. Many dogs licensee anesthetized without a pre-anesthetic required three people to restrain them . . " These animals were terrorized!

"[Varnes] had no pain management protocol in place for his surgical patients and did not provide pain relief for multiple animals" after surgery

"[Varnes] did not take any measures to prevent post-surgical hypothermia in animals or to adequately monitor them. The animals were simply put in cages after surgery. [Varnes] used no warming blankets or other heating devices and there was not even any bedding in the cages. In addition, the animals were not monitored after they were put in the cages."

Varnes "did not intubate cats for ovariohysterectomies." [Intubation is important to keep the airway open so that the animal can breath!)]

Varnes "talked on the telephone for up to 15 or 20 minutes while animals were under anesthesia, thereby unnecessarily increasing the anesthetic risk to the animals."

That isn't even all of what the staff alleged, you have to read it.

http://www.vetmed.state.mn.us/portals/22/VarnesRevocation.pdf

Varnes admitted many of these allegations, and denied others.

With his licensed finally revoked in September 2004, Varnes was eligible to reapply for license reinstatement 3 years later.

My question is this

Do not the veterinary boards bear some responsibility for the many victims of this man, for failure to take strong enough action sooner -- when this many had an 8 year multi-state record? Most especially -- when the GRAVE dangers Varnes posed were KNOWN in March 2004, when Minnesota could have revoked his licensed THEN, instead of allowing him to continue practising on "conditions" -- isn't the Minnesota Veterinary Board personally responsible for each and every one of Varnes' victims in the period of March 2004-September 2004?

I believe they are.

Many thanks to the dedicated staff -- other veterinarians and vet techs -- who obviously had to persist time and time again to finally get Minnesota to stop this guy from practising.

But my question is --

Is he now headed to YOUR state?

Links:

http://www.pet-abuse.com/cases/2732/MN/US/

http://www.vetmed.state.mn.us/portals/22/Varnes.pdf

http://www.in.gov/apps/pla/litigation/viewer.aspx?id=10094

http://www.in.gov/apps/pla/litigation/viewer.aspx?id=10092

http://www.in.gov/apps/pla/litigation/viewer.aspx?id=10090

http://www.poynter.org/resource/71570/0915-Main-A-002-F.pdf