Saturday, March 29, 2008

Unmonitored Dog Dies Alone Overnight After Dental in Clinic of Crosby, Texas Vet Harold Wagers

Three days before Christmas, in 2004, "Lilly" the English Bulldog was brought into the office of Crosby, Texas vet Harold Wagers for oral surgery and teeth cleaning. When her owner called to see how things were going, someone at the clinic told her that Lilly had regurgitated food during surgery, but was recovering. Wagers said he had instructed Lilly's owner that she should be "NPO" (no food or water) before the surgery. Lilly continued to vomit.

"At the time of clinic closing, Lilly was still recumbant." (Lying on her side.) Without consulting Lilly's owner, "Wagers decided to keep the dog overnight at the clinic, but no one was at the clinic to do after-hours monitoring. Sometime during the night, Lilly died. A necropsy noted that the probably cause of death was aspiration of gastric content."

The Board said that "Dr. Wagers did not exercise the same degree of humane care, skill and diligence in treating patients as is ordinarily used in the same or similar circumstances by average members of the veterinary medical profession in good standing in Crosby, Texas . . . the patient posed an elevated risk due to the vomiting that occurred during and after surgery. The dog was observed for less than two hours before the clinic closed. Dr. Wagers should have consulted with the owner about the need for continued monitoring, and given the owner the option of an after-hours facility or monitoring at home."

OK, so violations, substandard care, and dead dog. What does the vet board do?

They simply "formally reprimanded" Wagers.

Wow, what strong action. NOT. With pet protectors like the Texas Board of Veterinary Medical Examiners, no wonder vets don't care if our pets die. Bet vets like Wagers live in fear of you people, huh? NOT.

This is a good example of the awful things that can happen to your pet when they are left unmonitored, alone overnight in a cage at a vet "hospital."

Thursday, March 27, 2008

Virginia's Dr. Thomas Kawasaki: A Long Record

Veterinary Boards -- including Virginia -- dismiss the vast majority of complaints they receive. In Virginia, in 2005, only 26% of complaints resulted in discipline.

So, it is the rare and unusual veterinarian who amasses a disciplinary history with a many entries as Virginia's Thomas Kawasaki. This record (available online at the Virginia Vet Board website) includes:

1988 -- Dr. Kawasaki is disciplined by the Board for allowing a person not licensed as a vet in the state of Virginia to perform surgery (spay) on a dog. Reprimand; $500 fine; order to cease and desist from allowing persons unlicensed in VA to perform duties requiring licensure.

1991 -- Dr. Kawasaki is disciplined for ordering surgery without doing pre-operative bloodwork or taking into account prior post-operative bloodwork (The document says that the dogs scrotal sacs were "infected as a result of suspected toxemia of the kidneys following a neutering procedure which had been performed a few weeks earlier. It doesn't say of Kawasaki performed the surgery that led to the kidney toxemia and thus infected scrotal sacs. Hmm . . .)

The vet board gave Kawasaki a reprimand only.

1993 -- Dr. Kawasaki removed a tumor during surgery from a dog named "Claudette" without verifying that it was the tumor that was supposed to be removed. In the same
case, the Board found that he failed to ensure adequate recordkeeping, and failed to keep adequate records regarding anesthetics or medication provided to the dog during surgery.

Again -- what did the Board do? Reprimand ONLY.

1997 (February) -- The Veterinary Board suspends Kawasaki's license as a result of an incident which involved his ingestion of drugs he had diverted (taken) from his Veterinary practice.

1997 (March) -- The Board reinstates Kawasaki's license and puts him on probation.

1999 -- The Board lifts the probation on Kawasaki's license.

2002 -- An inspection of Kawasaki's clinic reveals numerous problems including problems with the drug inventory, the controlled substances distribution log, presence of expired medications in working stock. Also the "surgery suite was not reserved for surgery only . . . the registration certificate for the x-ray machine was not available . . . autoclave packs did not always contain an internal monitor . . . "

Penalty of $250 and additional inspection.

What is of greatest concern to me in this vet's record is his 1991 and 1993 violations, which raise serious questions about his patient care. That combined with the inspection findings as well as the other violations I believe should cause great concern in the mind of anyone who is a current or potential future client of this vet.

Links:

http://www.dhp.state.va.us/Notices/VetMed/0301001524/0301001524Order06181988.pdf

http://www.dhp.state.va.us/Notices/VetMed/0301001524/0301001524Order12041991.pdf

http://www.dhp.state.va.us/Notices/VetMed/0301001524/0301001524Order02121997.pdf

http://www.dhp.state.va.us/Notices/VetMed/0301001524/0301001524Order03211997.pdf


http://www.dhp.state.va.us/Notices/VetMed/0301001524/0301001524Order04081999.pdf

http://www.dhp.state.va.us/Notices/VetMed/0301001524/0301001524Order04091999.pdf

http://www.dhp.state.va.us/Notices/VetMed/0301001524/0301001524Order02052002.pdf

http://www.dhp.state.va.us/Notices/VetMed/0301001524/0301001524Order07242003.pdf

http://www.dhp.state.va.us/Notices/VetMed/0301001524/0301001524Order04162004.pdf

Update:

As my readers have noticed, I long ago turned off "comments" for a variety of reasons, and any clarifications or additional information I post here is entirely voluntary on my part with respect to "blogged about" vets here. I will rarely do so, and this is one of those rare occasions.

Today I received a rather passionate and heartfelt defense of this vet from someone involved in ferret rescue in Virginia. In this communication, the writer extolled Kawasaki's work with/for ferrets, referring to him as "brilliant", "compassionate," and a "good vet" who is "human" and has made a "few mistakes" over his long career. This writer posited that if this vet were not in practice, the world would be a far worse place for ferrets and ferret rescue in particular.

Out of respect for the apparent sincerity of that testimonial, I print this here.

In spite of this rather compelling and apparently sincere appeal, however, I nonetheless believe that he and others should find cause for concern in this record. I repeat that there are few vets with more than a few violations in their history, although there are many with more shocking ones.

When do a "few mistakes" become a pattern? You need to answer that question for yourself.

You should read the disciplinary history of not only this vet, but any vet you are considering.

Wednesday, March 26, 2008

Texas Vet Euthanized Dog Against Owners Wishes; Tells Owner the Dog Died on its Own

Plano Texas Vet Paul Burnside was working at the North Texas Emergency Pet Clinic (NTEPC) in Carrolton, Texas, when a Dallas resident brought his dog to NTEPC for "vomiting, diarrhea, and lethargy." Burnside, according to the Board document, found that the dog was "severely ill" (although the nature of the illness is not specified, and there is no mention of any tests at all), and reportedly recommended "aggressive treatment." The owner declined due to "financial constraints." Burnside then recommended euthanasia of the dog, which the owner also declined.

Would the owner have possibly come up with the money to treat the dog if given some more time? Would the dog have lived? We will never know, because this vet decided to take matters into his own hands.

According to the vet board document:

"Dr. Burnside decided on his own to euthanize the dog and he told the owner that the dog died while awaiting discharge. He stated in the patient record . . . 'the patient expired on his own.' He also altered the invoice for another animal previously euthanized to account for the Euthasol actually used for [this] dog. Controlled substances records were also altered to attribute Euthasol to another animal."

The Texas Veterinary Board found Dr. Burnside in violation of:

The professional standard of humane treatment, and
Rules related to Honesty, Integrity and Fair Dealing

So, what did the Board do about this egregious behavior?

They gave Burnside a Formal Reprimand. That's it. No fine, no suspension, no probation. What a joke.

Whose right is it to decide when an animal should be euthanized? The owner's, not the vets. Do we know whether or not this dog would have lived if Paul Burnside hadn't taken matters into his own hands and killed him? No, we don't. Perhaps the owner would have come up with the money for treatment. Perhaps the dogs codition was not fatal and he would have lived. Who knows -- there is no mention of any tests or any actual diagnosis, so it's not clear what "aggressive" and expensive treatment Burnside recommended that the owner declined, or what that treatment was for.

What is clear, is that this vet decided to kill this dog, against the wishes of his owner, and then lied about it -- altering hospital records and more. YET, all the Texas Vet Board sees fit to do is give him a reprimand.

Another interesting fact about this case -- Burnside was reported to the Board not by the owner, but by his boss, Kirk Esmond, President of the Board of Directors of the North Texas Emergency Pet Clinic. I personally thank Esmond for being so outraged by this behavior that he reported Burnside.

Links:

http://www.tbvme.state.tx.us/Board%20Minutes/Minutes_06_15_06.pdf

Tuesday, March 25, 2008

The Death of the Dachshund Magoo Two Days Before Christmas Eve While in the "Care" of Paul Holmberg, Minnesota Vet

This one may make you cry.

Paul Holmberg is a Minnesota vet who was the owner of Phalen Park Veterinary Clinic in St. Paul Minnesota, and practised there, in 2000.

An owner, "M.M.", brought his dachshund Magoo, 14, to Holmberg for a second opinion about a possible hernia.

The Board document says:

[Holmberg] "did not maintain any veterinary medical record of the . . . appointment with Magoo. The only record is a receipt dated November 28, 2000 for an office charge with a notation "poss. inguinal hernia."

"Surgery was scheduled for December 21, 2000." [PLEASE NOTE" This is nearly a month later]. Holmberg "did not perform or offer to perform any pre-surgical laboratory screenings on Magoo. [Holmberg] performed the surgery at about 4:00pm. He corrected bilateral inguinal hernias and an umbilical hernia . . . Magoo was not put on a warmig blanket after the surgery."

That night, Magoo's owner was told that the surgery was a success and that he could pick Magoo up the next morning.

Holmberg, the vet, left the clinic that night at about 9:30pm. And when he did, he LEFT MAGOO UNATTENDED IN A CARRIER overnight, alone, at the clinic.

When Holmberg's assistant arrived in the morning, "she found that Magoo was cold to the touch and difficult to wake." This assistant brought Magoo out to see his owner who showed up that morning, and when she did, Magoo was cold and shaking.

The document said that Holmberg arrived later and that he put Magoo next to a space heater. The document says that "The dog had not urinated since the surgery." Certainly this was an emergency - but it seems that nothing was done about it.

Holmberg gave this dog, who had not urinated, sub-q fluids, torbutrol, and diuretics. But he did not give Magoo IVs, and he did not put him on a warming blanket.

That night Magoo's owner came back. It was now two days before Christmas Eve. Holmberg told the owners that he needed to keep Magoo overnight.

According to the Board document, Holmberg took Magoo home with him. (I am not so sure I believe that. Wouldn't it be a bit out of character for a man who left this dog alone in a CARRIER all night after surgery?)

Still, according to the Board document, that is what he did, and he gave more subqs and unspecified medicines to Magoo. It says that "The dog did not produce urine, did not respond to treatment, and died the following morning."

Merry Christmas to little Magoo's family.

In citing the "deficiencies" in the medical records, the Board said that:

"The record does not contain any medical history."
". . . the record . . . does not explain what type of post-surgical complications occurred, does not contain any post-surgical examination findings and does not contain any treatment plan to address the post-surgical complications."
"The record does not indicate that the dog died."

This board finding is a perfect example of how State Vet Board's merely cite "RECORD-KEEPING violations" when clearly, much more serious things went on -- and in fact, the lack of records indicate a lack of something else -- it's not merely that they DON'T write things down folks, although that's what the board documents would falsely lead you to believe.

The document further says that a Board investigation of the clinic found that Holmberg's clinic "did not meet minimum standards of acceptable practice for housing and sterile surgery in that all animals being held at [Holmberg's] clinic were housed in plastic portable carriers in the surgery room . . . [Holmberg] did not have an x-ray machine . . . "

The Board required Holmberg to get some training related to surgery and record-keeping, offer to do pre-surgical screenings, improve his post-surgical treatment of animals, and replace the carriers with cages. Holmberg's license was made "conditional" on him meeting these conditions . . . but I have to tell you, I don't really trust Boards to check up on these things.

LATE ADDITION TO BLOG:

So, here is why Magoo's person is my hero: He filed a lawsuit against Holmberg.

According to a document I found on the web, Magoo's person:

" . . . brought an action against Holmberg in Ramsey County conciliation court, claiming that his dog died because Holmberg illegally advised him and was running an illegitimate business. In July, the conciliation court judge awarded Mierva $350 in compensatory damages and $500 in punitive damages; in August, Holmberg removed the action to district court."

Bottom line is, after this award, Holmberg "moved for partial summary judgment" to limit the owners damage to the "fair market value" of Magoo. Magoo was a 14-year old dachshund, so guess what the market value is?

"When there was no stipulation as to fair market value, a trial on damages was started on May 20. The district court granted Holmberg's motion to dismiss when Mierva stated that he had no evidence that established the dog's fair market value. This appeal follows."

Magoo's owner appealed this unsuccessfully.

So that's it folks: This scumbag Holmberg is basically arguing that his patient had no market value and so he should not be held for damages.

Do you ever want to take your pet to a vet who believes your pet has no value? Who is willing to argue that in court????

But we already knew he considered Magoo and his other patients value-less, didn't we? It was written all over those plastic carriers . . . .

LINKS:

http://www.vetmed.state.mn.us/portals/22/PaulHolmbergOrder.pdf

http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/getcase.pl?court=mn&vol=appunpub%5C0405%5Copa031106-0511&invol=1

Monday, March 24, 2008

What Do We Do with the Drugged Out Veterinarian, Installment #2

Ah, what a temptation it must be to be able to access narcotics -- at the stroke of a pen. Or at least it would seem so, since it's a temptation so many vets seem unable to avoid. If the behavior only endangered the vet, I wouldn't be writing about it here. But you see -- you don't really want your pet under the scalpel of a vet under the influence, do you?

One such vet is California's Heather Kerr, who ingested such a staggering amount of narcotics (which she obtained under the guise of having a legitimate veterinary use, but then instead took herself!) over a period of 14 years while practising veterinary medicine that it can scarcely be believed.

In November of 2007 a "Decision and Order" went into affect based on a settlement Kerr entered into with the California Veterinary Board, which included a disciplinary order placing her on probation for 5 years. Oh, yeah, the board revoked her license but STAYED the revocation, which means they didn't REALLY revoke it -- she can keep right on practising. And in fact today I found the website www.kerrequine.com, "Kerr Equine Services" -- marketing her "equine sports medicine and surgery." SURGERY?

Um, if you are going to be taking your horse to this woman, there are a few things you ought to know. And before you say -- "Aw, that was over six months ago, she's probably clean by now!" -- Just remember, this woman abused drugs repeatedly over the course of 14 years, do you really think she's clean now? Oh, yeah, she's supposed to be in a rehab program and is supposed to be submitting "biological fluid samples" -- but do you trust her operating on your horse?

Here is the deal: The causes for discipline cited were:

UNPROFESSIONAL CONDUCT: SELF-ADMINISTERING CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES

Kerr "purchased, possessed, and handled Oxycodone, under the guise that the narcotics would be prescribed, administered, or dispensed for a legitimate medical purpose in the course of professional practice . . . In 2002 [Kerr] purchased 14,000 tablets of Oxycodone . . . In 2003 [Kerr] purchased 13,000 tablets of Oxycodone . . In 2004 [Kerr] purchased 15,000 tablets of Oxycodone . . . In 2005 [Kerr] purchased 30,000 tablets of Oxycodone . . . In 2006 through April [the beginning of the year] [Kerr] purchased 5,000 tablets of Oxycodone."

"[Kerr] admittedly began diverting and self-administering 4 to 5 tablets of Oxycodone per day but gradually increased dosage so that by September 2006 she was taking 25 to 30 tablets per day."

Kerr "admittedly self-administered Demerol and Morphine on an irregular basis, during the time period between May 1992 and September 2006."

OK, so I looked up Oxycodone and APAP, and this combination is commonly known as Percocet. Could this woman possible take 25-30 percocet a day for so many years? Aside from the "admitted" drug abuse -- does anything else seem weird to you?

Let's do some math.

Kerr said she "gradually" worked up to 25 to 30 tablets of percocet per day.

This is quite unbelievable. But looking at the statistics for her orders 2002-2005, let's just say for the sake of argument that by 2002, she was already up to 25 per day.

25 times 365 days in the year is 9,125. She ordered 14,000 tablets that year. What happened to the nearly 5,000 she didn't gobble?

And at her height, she was supposed to be ingesting 30 of these per day. 30 times 365 is 10,950. Yet, in 2005, she ordered 30,000 of them. What happened to the 19,000 tablets she didn't gobble?

Is it even possible for someone to take 25-30 a day and survive? Apparently so -- there are people who have done it -- (see http://www.drugtalk.com/percocet/drugthread.php/t-175550.html); but you would be really messed up and not in any shape to practice any kind of medicine!

But to consume 30,000 pills, she would have to take over 80 a day. And that's just not possible So -- I ask again -- what about the other 19,000 pills?

This Board document doesn't accuse her of selling, and I have no proof of that. But it sure seems fishy to me.

Academically speaking, according to
http://www.prescription-drug-rehab.com/oxycodone.html, "The major source of oxycodone to the street has been through forged prescriptions, professional diversion through unscrupulous pharmacists, doctors, and dentists . . . " etc.

So hypothetically speaking of course, if a vet WERE selling this drug -- let's say, 19,000 tabs in a year -- how much black market income would that yield? According to that same article, oxycodone sells on the black market for about 50 cents to $1 per milligram. Let's split the difference at 75 cents. At 5 mgs a tablet, let's say, that's 3.75 each. 19,000 would be $71,250.

Now, I'm not accusing anyone of anything, and the reader is reminded that there is nothing in the state findings saying that Dr. Kerr ever did such a thing.

But it's all very interesting . . . that and the unnaccounted for, ungobbled 19,000 pills.

Back to the safety of our pets -- why would someone totally high on percocet NOT be someone you want operating on your pet?

Well, some people describe the feeling they get on this drug as "zoned out." If someone has ingested 30 of these babies in a day, it's a pretty good bet they don't have their wits about them to practice good medicine on you pet.

Sunday, March 23, 2008

What Do We Do with The Drugged Out (and Allegedly Negligent) Vet? Installment 1

This is the first drugged out vet we will talk about but it won't be the last. There are a lot of these . . . and this story shows that drug use by a veterinarian may not be a victimless crime -- because their drugged out state effects their ability to do their jobs and this of couse can endanger the life of pets.

This one is Todd Alan Cooney, DVM, of North East Animal Clinic in Kokomo, Indiana.

In March of 2005, the State of Indiana filed a complaint against Todd Cooney, citing the following facts:

"On or about January 31, 2005, the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) reported to the Indiana Office of the Attorney General that [Cooney] had been under investigation for failure to comply with Federal Requirements pertaining to controlled substances. As a result, [Cooney] surrendered his DEA registration."

"On or about August 23rd, 2004, [Cooney] was found at his residence by family members unresponsive due to an intravenous overdose of Ketamine and was hospitalized. [Cooney's] family discovered used syringes and multiple vials of ketamine on the premises."

"[Cooney] entered the substance abuse treatment program at Rush in Chicago, Illinois in September 2004 . . . [Cooney]relapsed and began using ketamine and valium while working at his clinic shortly after his release from Rush . . . [Cooney] subsequently entered a substance abuse treatment program in New Mexico but failed to complete the program."

"[Cooney] has exhibited signs of being under the influence while on duty at his practice. Staff report [Cooney] has appeared slow, staggering, and confused while at work."

"On or about November 5, 2004, [Cooney] was scheduled to spay a dog and repair an umbilical hernia. [Cooney] performed surgery but noted only an umbilical hernia in the medical records. Subsequent lab tests and exploratory surgery revealed that [Cooney] failed to spay the animal."

"On or about January 11, 2005, Marion County Sherriff Deputies were called by [Cooney's] sister . . . who reported [Cooney] had physically assaulted her after she attempted to determine whether [Cooney] had any needles/syringes at her parents home. [His sister] was concerned that [Cooney] may have exposed her children to needles . . . "

"[Cooney] has admitted to the DEA that he has abused Ketamine . . . On or about February 8, 2005, the Office of the Attorney General received additional information from the DEA that the police had been called to [Cooney's] veterinary practice over an altercation between [Cooney] and other staff members."

The Board allowed Cooney to continue practising on probation. For one year, the terms of this probation included limiting his practice to work as a research and diagnostic parasitologist at Purdue University -- in other words, thankfully not working at a vet clinic. There were no fines, and at this time, Cooney would no longer be barred from working at a clinic.

In 2007, the Board decided that it would allow Cooney to reapply for his DEA licensed.

And, quite frighteningly, I found this website with a listing for a Kokomo, Indiana business("Noah's Ark Kennels and Grooming") declaring: "We are now a full veterinary clinic. Dr. Todd Cooney is back. $5.00 off grooming."

OK, you couldn't PAY me to take my pet there.

There is also a cryptic agenda item on the agenda of the Indiana Controlled Substances Advisory Committee for September 28, 2007 -- pretty recently. Under "Personal Appearances" this agenda lists Todd Cooney, DVM, and next to his name are the words "Positive Response." Does this mean he tested positive on a drug test?

Links:

http://www.in.gov/apps/pla/litigation/viewer.aspx?id=10026

Thursday, March 20, 2008

The Not-So-Innocent Georgia Vet Who Held a Dog Hostage

In Fall of 2007, the story broke of Josh Gomez and his pup, a Border Collie named Pilot -- who was held hostage by Georgia Veterinarian Garry "Innocent."

Gomez took Pilot in to see Innocent at PetFIRST Animal Hospital in Duluth, Georgia, where Pilot was diagnosed with parvovirus. Parvovirus is an intestinal virus that can be lethal to dogs. According to news accounts, Innocent gave Gomez an estimate of $1,125 to treat Pilot. But when Gomez, a music teacher, returned to get Pilot, he was presented with a bill for several hundred dollars more than that estimate.

Having made arrangements to get the money needed to pay the original estimate, Gomez paid the $1,125. But Innocent refused to release Pilot until the balance was paid, and then immediately began tacking on boarding fees of $27 a day additional for every day he held Pilot hostage.

Innocent told Gomez that if he didn't come up with the balance (which was growing by the day as he held the dog), he would turn the dog over to animal control, where he might be euthanized. Later, after the media got wind of this story and it began to get some publicity, Innocent changed his threat -- saying instead he would give Pilot away to someone elese.

Gomez filed a lawsuit in Gwinnett Superior Court to try to stop Innocent from sending Pilot to the shelter.

But then a good samaritan stepped forward, to pay the balance of the bill, and Pilot and Gomez were reunited.

Although Georgia law allows vets to "dispose of" pets when a bill is unpaid, considering the animal abandoned -- the law is one thing, and what's right is another.

In our book, Dr. Garry Innocent of PetFIRST Animal Hospital in Duluth, Georgia is a
BAD VET.

Links:

http://www.itchmo.com/man-says-vet-refuses-to-release-dog-because-of-unpaid-bill-2871

http://www.itchmo.com/dog-released-from-veterinarian-after-good-samaritan-pays-owners-bill-2942